Senators oppose base closings

New England senators are not pleased with the idea of several military bases closing on the recommendation of the Obama administration.

President Obama will ask Congress to approve a new round of domestic base closures, Defense Secretary Leon Panetta said Thursday, although the timing was left vague and there is little chance lawmakers would agree to it in a presidential election year.

Sens. Jeanne Shaheen and Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire, as well as Sens. Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins of Maine, quickly defended the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard in Kittery, Maine. The four lawmakers said another round of base closings doesn't make sense in advancing national security or saving money.

The Base Closure and Realignment Commission rejected a Pentagon recommendation in 2005 to shut the base. The decision came after state and local elected officials, businesses, civic groups and others quickly formed a coalition to beat back the proposed shutdown. The base also had been targeted in 1993.

A lot is at stake. Robert Ross, executive director of the state Office of Military Affairs, said the sub base pumps $4.5 billion a year into the economy in salaries and spending for everything from office supplies to gas. At least 15,000 jobs are tied to the operation of the base, he said.

He said he is always concerned about the base's future. "There are no guarantees when you're dealing with BRAC," Ross said.

Less than seven years after local and state officials, business owners and civic groups beat back recommendations to shut a submarine base in Connecticut, the Obama administration has again raised the specter of base closings.

Connecticut Rep. Joe Courtney and Sens. Joe Lieberman and Richard Blumenthal, who are members of the House and Senate armed services committees, said in a news release that Obama's proposal has drawn bipartisan opposition and would be "dead on arrival."

Courtney, whose district is home to the submarine base in Groton, called it a weak proposal because the administration did not include the cost of closing bases, which he said is enormous. In an interview yesterday, he said residents have been nervous for years, "convinced that it's only a matter of time" before the issue of base closings returns.

Tony Sheridan, president and chief executive of the Chamber of Commerce of Eastern Connecticut, said businesses are "always anxious about this."

"We've lived through several base closing attempts," he said. "Needless to say, you don't take it for granted. When we hear about a base closing it gets our attention."

The Government Accountability Office said the BRAC Commission estimate of $21 billion cost over the six years to shut bases increased to $35 billion. Courtney and the senators from Connecticut, Maine and New Hampshire cited that dollar amount as they criticized talk of a new round of closings.

"The net savings was so weak you have to scratch your head," Courtney said. "How serious is this?"

Shaheen said lawmakers don't know that another round of base closings will save money and as a result, the suggestion is premature.

"I'd be surprised if we see anything in 2013 but we need to be vigilant," she said.

Portsmouth Naval Shipyard, which Shaheen says employs 5,000 workers from Maine and New Hampshire, was spared in the last round of base closings. Brunswick Naval Air Station was shut.

Sheridan said the high cost to close bases could help save Connecticut's sub base.

"I'm deriving some comfort from the fact that this is a situation where they're trying to save money," he said. "The results so far from closing bases is dismal."

Sheridan also said he was encouraged by a visit by Panetta in November to Electric Boat, the General Dynamics Corp. subsidiary in Groton that manufactures submarines. Panetta said the United States must protect its military industrial base and said he was extremely reluctant to impose more cuts if a congressional panel failed to agree on a deficit-trimming plan. (next page »)