Hi 38° | Lo 24°

Belarus – beacon of freedom? – blasts U.S. invasions of privacy

Calling out hypocrisy by resorting to hypocrisy is not usually a tactic that will win you an argument. But no one seems to have told Belarus.

Known as Europe’s last dictatorship, the country has a dismal record when it comes to human rights. However, that hasn’t stopped it from releasing a new report this week, “Human Rights Violations in Certain Countries in 2012,” which savages the United States for “unlawful interference with privacy.”

The report blasts the Obama administration’s recent renewal of the Foreign Intelligence and Surveillance Act. It also points the finger at “the use of GPS devices to monitor targeted citizens without a court permission” as an example of privacy violations.

The report is a clear attempt to paint Belarus in a more positive light and to justify its own abuses.

Last year, I reported on an outstanding Swedish investigation that uncovered how surveillance was used in Belarus to track down, arrest and prosecute protesters who attended an anti-government protest rally following the 2010 Belarusian presidential election. The country’s state security agency, the KGB, had used location data records to retrospectively identify protesters who gathered in a square in the country’s capital, Minsk. According to the Swedish report, “those who criticize the regime in Belarus vanish without a trace.” Index on Censorship says the country uses “surveillance techniques which allow the state to intercept all online traffic.”

It might be convenient politics to attack other countries for “unlawful interference with privacy,” and some of the criticisms are valid. But ultimately it feels like getting a lecture on the Geneva Conventions from a convicted war criminal.

(Ryan Gallagher reports regularly on surveillance technology for Slate’s Future Tense.)

Legacy Comments0
There are no comments yet. Be the first!
Post a Comment

You must be registered to comment on stories. Click here to register.