Cloudy
30°
Cloudy
Hi 31° | Lo 23°

Book TV: Cable pundits and their literary efforts

  • Sean Hannity talks to the live audience during the taping of Fox News Channel's "Hannity" which is on the road celebrating the network's 15th anniversary, held at Centennial Olympic Park in Atlanta, Thursday, Oct. 6, 2011. (AP Photo/John Amis)

    Sean Hannity talks to the live audience during the taping of Fox News Channel's "Hannity" which is on the road celebrating the network's 15th anniversary, held at Centennial Olympic Park in Atlanta, Thursday, Oct. 6, 2011. (AP Photo/John Amis)

  • Rachel Maddow, left, host of "The Rachel Maddow Show" on MSNBC, and Lawrence O'Donnell, host of "The Last Word," take part in a panel discussion at the NBC Universal summer press tour, Tuesday, Aug. 2, 2011, in Beverly Hills, Calif. (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello)

    Rachel Maddow, left, host of "The Rachel Maddow Show" on MSNBC, and Lawrence O'Donnell, host of "The Last Word," take part in a panel discussion at the NBC Universal summer press tour, Tuesday, Aug. 2, 2011, in Beverly Hills, Calif. (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello)

  • Conservative talk show host Sean Hannity speaks during a debate against liberal Salt Lake City mayor Rocky Anderson, Friday, May 4, 2007, in Salt Lake City, Utah. (AP Photo/Douglas C. Pizac)

    Conservative talk show host Sean Hannity speaks during a debate against liberal Salt Lake City mayor Rocky Anderson, Friday, May 4, 2007, in Salt Lake City, Utah. (AP Photo/Douglas C. Pizac)

  • FILE - In a Jan. 1 2005 file photo provided by Democracy Radio,  Ed Schultz laughs at a caller's joke during his nationally-syndicated progressive program.   MSNBC's Schultz is off the air for more than a week after calling a fellow talk-show host a vulgar term. MSNBC said the network and Schultz mutually agreed on a suspension that will take him off the air until June 6. On his radio show, the liberal commentator referred to conservative host Laura Ingraham as a "right-wing slut." Schultz apologized on MSNBC on Wednesday, May 25, 2011 to Ingraham, his family, MSNBC and viewers for the remark. (AP Photo/Democracy Radio via PR NEWSWIRE)

    FILE - In a Jan. 1 2005 file photo provided by Democracy Radio, Ed Schultz laughs at a caller's joke during his nationally-syndicated progressive program. MSNBC's Schultz is off the air for more than a week after calling a fellow talk-show host a vulgar term. MSNBC said the network and Schultz mutually agreed on a suspension that will take him off the air until June 6. On his radio show, the liberal commentator referred to conservative host Laura Ingraham as a "right-wing slut." Schultz apologized on MSNBC on Wednesday, May 25, 2011 to Ingraham, his family, MSNBC and viewers for the remark. (AP Photo/Democracy Radio via PR NEWSWIRE)

  • **FILE**Fox News commentator Bill O'Reilly appears on the Fox News show, "The O'Reilly Factor," on Jan. 18, 2007 in New York. O'Reilly and Geraldo Rivera said Friday, April 6, 2007, there were no hard feelings after they engaged in a shouting match   over illegal immigration on Fox News Channel's "The O'Reilly Factor" Thursday night.(AP Photo/Jeff Christensen)

    **FILE**Fox News commentator Bill O'Reilly appears on the Fox News show, "The O'Reilly Factor," on Jan. 18, 2007 in New York. O'Reilly and Geraldo Rivera said Friday, April 6, 2007, there were no hard feelings after they engaged in a shouting match over illegal immigration on Fox News Channel's "The O'Reilly Factor" Thursday night.(AP Photo/Jeff Christensen)

  • book

    book

  • FILE-This  March 26, 2007 file photo released by NSADAQ, shows  Dylan Ratigan posing on the set of CNBC's "Fast Money," at the NASDAQ MarketSite in New York. Ratigan's not shy about spouting off; he apologized last week for treating a Florida congresswoman rudely during an interview about health care reform. He proved a bad fit in the morning. MSNBC is cutting his show in half and moving it to 4 p.m. ET before Chris Matthews.  (AP Photo/NASDAQ, HO) ** NO SALES **

    FILE-This March 26, 2007 file photo released by NSADAQ, shows Dylan Ratigan posing on the set of CNBC's "Fast Money," at the NASDAQ MarketSite in New York. Ratigan's not shy about spouting off; he apologized last week for treating a Florida congresswoman rudely during an interview about health care reform. He proved a bad fit in the morning. MSNBC is cutting his show in half and moving it to 4 p.m. ET before Chris Matthews. (AP Photo/NASDAQ, HO) ** NO SALES **

  • book

    book

  • An undated photo provided by Henry Holt and Company shows the cover the book "Killing Kennedy:  The End of Camelot" by Bill O'Reilly and Martin Dugard. Henry Holt and Company announced Thursday Feb. 16, 2012 the book will come out this fall.  (AP Photo/Henry Holt and Company)

    An undated photo provided by Henry Holt and Company shows the cover the book "Killing Kennedy: The End of Camelot" by Bill O'Reilly and Martin Dugard. Henry Holt and Company announced Thursday Feb. 16, 2012 the book will come out this fall. (AP Photo/Henry Holt and Company)

  • book

    book

  • book

    book

  • book

    book

  • book<br/><br/>

    book

  •  Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I

    Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I

  •  Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I

    Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I

  •  Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I

    Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I

  • Sean Hannity talks to the live audience during the taping of Fox News Channel's "Hannity" which is on the road celebrating the network's 15th anniversary, held at Centennial Olympic Park in Atlanta, Thursday, Oct. 6, 2011. (AP Photo/John Amis)
  • Rachel Maddow, left, host of "The Rachel Maddow Show" on MSNBC, and Lawrence O'Donnell, host of "The Last Word," take part in a panel discussion at the NBC Universal summer press tour, Tuesday, Aug. 2, 2011, in Beverly Hills, Calif. (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello)
  • Conservative talk show host Sean Hannity speaks during a debate against liberal Salt Lake City mayor Rocky Anderson, Friday, May 4, 2007, in Salt Lake City, Utah. (AP Photo/Douglas C. Pizac)
  • FILE - In a Jan. 1 2005 file photo provided by Democracy Radio,  Ed Schultz laughs at a caller's joke during his nationally-syndicated progressive program.   MSNBC's Schultz is off the air for more than a week after calling a fellow talk-show host a vulgar term. MSNBC said the network and Schultz mutually agreed on a suspension that will take him off the air until June 6. On his radio show, the liberal commentator referred to conservative host Laura Ingraham as a "right-wing slut." Schultz apologized on MSNBC on Wednesday, May 25, 2011 to Ingraham, his family, MSNBC and viewers for the remark. (AP Photo/Democracy Radio via PR NEWSWIRE)
  • **FILE**Fox News commentator Bill O'Reilly appears on the Fox News show, "The O'Reilly Factor," on Jan. 18, 2007 in New York. O'Reilly and Geraldo Rivera said Friday, April 6, 2007, there were no hard feelings after they engaged in a shouting match   over illegal immigration on Fox News Channel's "The O'Reilly Factor" Thursday night.(AP Photo/Jeff Christensen)
  • book
  • FILE-This  March 26, 2007 file photo released by NSADAQ, shows  Dylan Ratigan posing on the set of CNBC's "Fast Money," at the NASDAQ MarketSite in New York. Ratigan's not shy about spouting off; he apologized last week for treating a Florida congresswoman rudely during an interview about health care reform. He proved a bad fit in the morning. MSNBC is cutting his show in half and moving it to 4 p.m. ET before Chris Matthews.  (AP Photo/NASDAQ, HO) ** NO SALES **
  • book
  • An undated photo provided by Henry Holt and Company shows the cover the book "Killing Kennedy:  The End of Camelot" by Bill O'Reilly and Martin Dugard. Henry Holt and Company announced Thursday Feb. 16, 2012 the book will come out this fall.  (AP Photo/Henry Holt and Company)
  • book
  • book
  • book
  • book<br/><br/>
  •  Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I
  •  Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I
  •  Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old? I

Did you know that black churches opposed to gay rights are hypocritical because of the gay men in many church choirs? That cruise missiles stored in Louisiana had fungus on their wings? Or that Bill O’Reilly didn’t have sex till he was 20 years old?

If not, you have some books to crack. Anchors at the major cable news channels are spreading their sundry insights in bound form this fall. And their 24-7 news operations can barely accommodate plugs for all the new releases, which come courtesy of CNN’s Piers Morgan; Fox News’s Bill O’Reilly and Brian Kilmeade; and MSNBC’s Chris Matthews, Joe Scarborough and Al Sharpton.

There was a time when TV personalities who took to long-form writing tended to receive warm critical receptions. When Walter Cronkite published his memoir, A Reporter’s Life, in 1997, a New York Times reviewer declared that “Walter Cronkite is a serious man and this is a serious message.” Tom Brokaw’s The Greatest Generation (1998) also received critical acclaim – though the Washington Post dinged it as “a bit lightweight intellectually.”

Yet when O’Reilly published his historical thriller Killing Jesus in September, USA Today pooh-poohed that the book’s “one-sentence paragraphs read like a movie poster,” and neither the Post nor the Times deigned to run a review. “I have not read Mr. O’Reilly’s books myself, so I can’t really comment on them,” Times book review editor Pamela Paul emailed me.

How about a collective review, then? O’Reilly’s trilogy – Killing Lincoln and Killing Kennedy preceded the current iteration – has commandeered the bestseller lists for three years running. Other cable books also make appearances on those lists. Together, they have to matter.

This diverse set of titles defies easy encapsulation. After plowing through 19 of them by 13 cable personalities, I grabbed a crowbar to force them into four categories.

Repetition, repetition, repetition

Cable hosts get a daily rush from knowing that hundreds of thousands, if not millions, tune in just to hear what they have to say about stuff. So when it comes time to do a book, why not repeat the exercise?

Such appears to be the thinking behind Morgan’s book. Titled Shooting Straight, it could be nicknamed Transcripting Straight, in that a significant portion of the book consists of highlights from his eponymous nightly program on CNN. At one point, he recounts the early parts of an interview with Tony Blair, with whom Morgan had feuded:

“ ‘Mr. Blair,’ I started, ‘how are you.’ ‘Very well, Piers, how are you doing.’ ‘It’s been a while.’ He laughed. ‘It has indeed.’ The interview itself was informative and valuable.’ ”

(Morgan says the diary format borrows from books he’s written in Britain – and that unlike other cable hosts, he doesn’t get any writing assistance. “It’s all me.”)

Fox News’s Sean Hannity similarly doesn’t mind repeating himself in Let Freedom Ring: Winning the War of Liberty Over Liberalism (2002), writing, “I said it on radio and TV at the time and I’ll say it again here . . .”

Doesn’t matter what he said next, because his audience had already heard it. Twice.

Also in this category is The Joy of Hate (2012), in which Greg Gutfeld, a co-host of the outstanding Fox News program The Five, manages to soft-pedal climate change, dismiss the threat of bullying and hammer Sandra Fluke, among other persuasive feats attempted each hour on Fox News.

Research, research, research

Cable hosts produce better books when they do research. Even quick research.

The three Killing books by O’Reilly and partner Martin Dugard have come out over three years, way too fast to contribute to the scholarship of the respective assassinations. Killing Lincoln, for example, withered under fact-checks from historians and was banned from one of the bookstores in Ford’s Theatre.

As for Killing Jesus, no one has yet taken issue with O’Reilly’s take on Cleopatra’s “small breasts.”

Fine points notwithstanding, it’s tough to scoff at millions of Americans brushing up on their history with O’Reilly’s books. Though intellectuals bemoan the absence of rigor, the real comparison here isn’t O’Reilly vs. Robert Caro. It’s O’Reilly vs. O’Reilly. Killing Jesus, that is, marks a big improvement over the author’s previous works, including Pinheads and Patriots: Where You Stand in the Age of Obama, the 2010 volume that alternates between bashing President Obama and proclaiming that Lassie is a patriot.

Speaking of patriots, pragmatic Republican ones preoccupy Scarborough in The Right Path: From Ike to Reagan, How Republicans Once Mastered Politics – and Can Again. Politico’s Mike Allen reported that “the buzz among GOP insiders is that The Right Path has the potential to galvanize conservatives in the way Barry Goldwater’s Conscience of a Conservative did half a century ago.” First, though, conservatives have to get through the book, which reads like a best-of compilation of campaign horse-race coverage written by a politician turned cable host.

In Twilight of the Elites: America After Meritocracy, Scarborough’s colleague Chris Hayes takes a stab at explaining the crisis of leadership across government and industry. The book has some great moments, including the part where he discusses the pitfalls of the meritocratic entry test for Manhattan’s Hunter College High School, which Hayes himself attended. Its main drawback is a case of what I’ll call MSNBCitis – a tendency to describe smart concepts in such grandiloquent terms that a reader can’t explain them later to a spouse.

MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow is the clear winner of the cable-news-host literary prize. In Drift: The Unmooring of American Military Power (2012), she explains why we’re always at war. Turns out we’ve lowered all the barriers that once gave the country pause about entering into armed conflict.

Though grafting cable formats onto books is generally a bad idea, it works for Maddow, who’s famous for churning out towering monologues on her MSNBC show. That training benefits Drift, which pairs storytelling with research and insight. For instance, in a chapter retracing the U.S. military’s occasional mishandling of its nuclear arsenal, Maddow writes, “While our nuclear armed cruise missiles were growing leading-edge wing fungus in the subtropical moisture of Louisiana, other US military flying hardware was having rather the opposite problem: in the words of Defense Industry Daily, they ‘were about to fly their wings off – and not just as a figure of speech.’ ”

The first line of Maddow’s acknowledgments hints at one secret to her success, a pointer that Bill “Ten Books in a Decade” O’Reilly might consider: “I’m the slowest writer on earth.”

Life before cable

When he signed on with MSNBC in 2011 at the age of 56, Sharpton had already spent a career crusading for civil rights, or spreading racial hatred, depending on your perspective.

Whatever the case, his cable career gets little attention in his new book, The Rejected Stone: Al Sharpton and the Path to American Leadership. In its place comes a screed on behalf of gay choir members, a full accounting of his relationship with President Obama and an unfulfilling admission that he made a “mistake” in connection with Tawana Brawley – the 15-year-old African American whose 1987 claim to have been gang-raped by a group of white men was promoted by Sharpton. It turned out to be a hoax.

There’s also top-shelf bombast in The Rejected Stone. Writing about hip-hop, Sharpton proclaims, “I still have the need, the desire, to try to drive this generation toward a greater understanding, to understand the roots of what it is they call their art form.”

Book bonus: Sharpton has dropped more than 160 pounds, a process that started with a question from his 5-year-old: “Daddy, why are you so fat?”

Fox News host Greta Van Susteren’s pre-cable life lacks the contours of Sharpton’s, but her work as a litigator propels parts of 2003’s My Turn at the Bully Pulpit: Straight Talk About the Things That Drive Me Nuts (with Elaine Lafferty). She unfurls a brutal take-down of tort reform, the movement toward restricting lawsuits, and destroys conventional wisdom about the woman who long ago sued McDonald’s over coffee burns.

What’s the appeal?

Why do we have so many cable-news-host books?

Is the industry channeling academe’s publish-or-perish imperative? “I don’t think it’s that,” Hayes says. “There are stories that we want to do that don’t make for good television.”

Clearly, though, they don’t always make for good books.

A year ago, Fox News host Megyn Kelly sat down with Douglas Brunt, the author of Ghosts of Manhattan, a novel about Wall Street excesses before the financial meltdown. “The novel is earning rave reviews, being compared to the works of Charles Dickens and Tom Wolfe,” Kelly noted.

Brunt is Kelly’s husband, which says something about book-promotion ethics at Fox News.

Almost every night on his show, Fox’s O’Reilly manages to promote a Killing title or two in the viewer-mail segment. “I really enjoyed Killing Jesus. You portrayed a brutal world, O’Reilly, by writing about Romans, the Jewish people and what they endured. Could we ever go in that direction again?” wrote Kitty Knoedler of Fairhope, Ala., in a missive recently read aloud by the host.

And if a news segment veers into the territory of a Killing book, expect a plug on The O’Reilly Factor. On Aug. 26, for example, O’Reilly played a clip from Martin Luther King Jr.’s “I Have a Dream” speech. Next line: “Now, if you want to know the inside story of that historic speech, we provide vivid detail in my book Killing Kennedy. You might find that very interesting.”

Other cablers resist that level of shamelessness, which is not to say that CNN and MSNBC are shy about talking up books by their people. As the government shutdown preoccupied television news in October, for instance, it was hard to catch MSNBC Hardball host Matthews without hearing about his new book, Tip and the Gipper: When Politics Worked.

Matthews being Matthews, the pitches were forthright or obnoxious, depending on your politics. “I’m asking everybody who watches Hardball, all the loyalists to me and this program, to go out and get this book now,” he said on his Oct. 9 show.

Morgan says he spoke with CNN President Jeff Zucker about promotional guidelines. “He’s happy for me to do shows” on CNN to promote Shooting Straight and to plug it “within reason on my own show,” Morgan relates.

“It’s a huge deal,” literary agent Howard Yoon notes via email when asked about the promotional head start of the cable news hosts. “They’re all big bestselling authors . . . because readers see their faces on TV every night.”

What we have here, then, is a group of millionaires advancing their fortunes, not to mention the brand recognition of their employers, with often mediocre literature. You might just call these people “a cohort of socially distant, blinkered, and self-dealing elites.” That’s among the more memorable lines from Hayes’s book.

Legacy Comments3

Are we to assume there are no errors in Maddows book? I have not read it, but if you are going to point out errors in Bill o's book...shouldn't you do the same for Maddow? And what is up with this new bold type??...Not a fan.

I read it. Trust me . . . it's much more accurate and well-researched than any other book in this column. But wait, I did find one mistake, she misquoted Thomas Jefferson in the book. Albeit I found that out by reading Jack Coleman at Newsbusters, so a grain of salt might be necessary.

There is hope for you

Post a Comment

You must be registered to comment on stories. Click here to register.