It was love at first sight for Sen. John McCain.
Looking back at his two victories in New Hampshire’s primary, the former naval aviator and Vietnam War hero turned longtime U.S. senator and 2008 Republican presidential nominee commented a couple of years ago that “there’s nothing quite as exciting as those last couple of weeks before the primary in all of American politics.”
But could John McCain, who nostalgically called New Hampshire his “second favorite state” after his home of Arizona, still win the first-in-the-nation presidential primary in the political climate that currently exists?
It’s a question that’s being asked with McCain’s passing this past weekend from brain cancer.
The opinions of some leading Granite State Republicans, including two who were key players in McCain’s 2000 and 2008 victories in New Hampshire, were mixed.
“I think he could (still win),” said Concord’s Steve Duprey, one of McCain’s closest friends and a top adviser on the senator’s two presidential campaigns.
“I think over the long run, John McCain’s assessment that America is a force for good in the world and the world is much worse off when we retreat from defending freedom and democracy will be in the forefront again. I think his recognition that Russia under Putin is an adversary, not an ally or friend, will be recognized,” added Duprey, a longtime Republican National Committeeman and a former New Hampshire GOP chairman.
“I think history will prove John McCain right,” he predicted.
That sentiment was echoed by former three-term Gov. John H. Sununu, who went on to serve as chief of staff to President George H.W. Bush and in later years steered the state Republican Party.
“I think New Hampshire still values individuals that care about national security. It still values people who don’t want giant-sized government. It values people who care about the individual. It values people who are believers in traditional values of the country,” Sununu said.
“I think New Hampshire still has the basic equations on issues that John McCain was able to stitch together,” Sununu added.
But Michael Dennehy – a senior advisor on both of the senator’s presidential campaigns – questioned whether a McCain-type Republican could win in the current political climate. For Dennehy, it’s less about a GOP dominated by President Donald Trump, who feuded with McCain in recent years, but rather about technology.
“John McCain was such a unique person. I don’t know if there’s another John McCain in this world. I don’t know if the John McCain campaign of 2000 and even 2008 is even achievable anymore because of this world we live in where social media dominates,” explained Dennehy, the Concord-based veteran GOP consultant.
“The town hall meeting has become so different and the media that surrounds candidates has become so different,” Dennehy added.
The ill will between Trump and McCain dates back to 2015. That’s when presidential candidate Trump argued McCain wasn’t a hero because he was captured during the Vietnam War. The two men repeatedly traded verbal fire during the presidential campaign and during Trump’s tenure to date in the White House. Even after McCain’s death, the feud has dominated headlines as Trump for two days refused to praise the late senator for his years of service to the country and his heroism as a prisoner of war until relenting.
Former NHGOP chair Jennifer Horn lamented that “there is a lot about John McCain’s passing that is deeply sad and the idea that a John McCain might not be able to do as well in today’s Republican Party makes me very, very sad.”
“I think that John McCain is an American classic and that he would always be able to make his case and that people would always respond very strongly and positively to him,” said Horn, who as the Republican nominee in the Second Congressional District campaigned alongside McCain in the 2008 general election.
“But there’s no question there are some elements of our party today who would reject the style and the legacy of John McCain and I think that is really to the detriment of both our party and our country,” added Horn, who as party chair often didn’t see eye to eye with Trump’s 2016 campaign team in New Hampshire.
Former state attorney general and longtime GOP consultant Tom Rath said he hopes a John McCain style Republican could still win in this day and age.
“Otherwise we would have lost something very precious, not just about the New Hampshire primary, but about our politics generally,” Rath said. “I continue to think that somebody who appeals to reason and decency will always have a chance.”
Rath was a top supporter of Ohio Gov. John Kasich in the 2016 Republican primary. Kasich, who came in second in New Hampshire to Trump, remains a critic of the president, and is mulling a 2020 primary challenge to Trump.
Rath said McCain and Kasich are “very different people but they both accord the electorate a huge amount of respect and don’t try to just get by with slogans and try to appeal to raw emotions.”
Both Kasich in 2016, and McCain in 2000 and 2008, were extremely accessible to New Hampshire voters. And Kasich took a page out of McCain’s “Straight Talk Express” bus as he campaigned in the last presidential election.
Duprey, who traveled with McCain across New Hampshire during those presidential runs, reflected that the senator “won because of his accessibility and authenticity. The way he ran town hall meetings. People heard about it quickly and it caught on. People used to say he welcomed Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, vegetarians and an occasional recovering socialist.”
Duprey also highlighted that McCain was able to laugh at himself.
“New Hampshire has a healthy skepticism of politicians,” Duprey explained. “People appreciated the fact that he didn’t put on airs, he didn’t come in with big entourages. The other thing that really helped him win is he’d admit to mistakes. He didn’t hold himself out as somebody perfect.”
And he added that “McCain called on everybody. He loved the battle. He loved the contest of ideas.”
Dennehy spotlighted McCain’s interaction with voters as a crucial contributing factor in his success in the New Hampshire primary.
“It was John McCain’s willingness to open himself up, listen for hours on end to the voters, and respond by telling them the truth,” he said.
Horn said McCain was special but his success with Granite Staters was very simple.
“He just really understood the spirit of New Hampshire voters, the independence of the Live Free or Die political mentality. I think his willingness to answer any question, no matter how difficult it was. That straight talk was not just a campaign slogan for him. He was direct, he was honest. I think people in New Hampshire really respected and appreciated it,” she said.
And she added that his patriotism was genuine.
“People in New Hampshire responded very strongly to his profound love of country,” Horn added. “I think there’s a lot of people in politics who talk that talk. There are very few people in the country, very few people in the world, who have walked that walk the way John McCain did.”
