Property taxes are the flip side of the so-called New Hampshire advantage, the state’s lack of a sales or income tax. They increase steadily, often bear little relation to an owner’s ability to pay, and, in these pandemic times, are an obligation that many households are finding harder to meet. Yet, the burden for homeowners could soon get significantly heavier. Here’s why, though I hope I’m wrong.
First, a few basics. No state relies more heavily on property taxes to fund government – including public schools – than New Hampshire. Local, state, and county property taxes combined cover two-thirds of the cost. In some communities taxes on commercial and industrial property, or expensive second homes, drastically lower the burden on residents. In Concord, not so much.
Tax bills are computed by multiplying the tax rate, currently $27.78 per $1,000 of valuation, by the property’s current market value as determined by assessors and after equalization by the state. The city of Concord sends out tax bills quarterly. The July bill was mailed earlier this month. The next bill comes in October.
The real estate website Zillow pegs the median value of a home in Concord at $256,283 and describes the local market as “very hot.” Zillow estimates that the median house gained 5.7% in value in the past year. Affordable homes, those under roughly $300,000, appreciated the most.
The 2018 tax bill on a $250,000 Concord home was $7,047.50, according to the city’s finance department. In 2019 that home’s value grew to $257,350 and though the city’s tax rate fell, the property’s tax bill grew to $7,149.18 for an increase of just under 1.5%. But that was then, before COVID-19, before the economic slump and massive job loss, before many employers learned that productivity didn’t suffer, and in some cases increased, when employees worked from home. Workers found that they regained hours of their life, and saved money by telecommuting.
Several local employers, I was told, recently notified their landlord that working from home has proved so successful that they are giving up their downtown digs. That sort of thing is happening all over America. Companies have discovered that they no longer need to occupy fancy chunks of prime real estate to turn a profit. Google and Facebook told most employees that they could work from home for the rest of the year. Twitter told its Manhattan employees that they could work from home forever.
The value of a commercial property is determined in good measure by the rents it can command and the occupancy rate. When those fall so does the value of the property. That is beginning to happen. That means, assuming municipal budgets hold steady, the difference will have to be made up by increasing residential property taxes. Ouch.
The same goes for retail property in the era of online sales. In 2003, Concord’s Steeplegate Mall was assessed at $55.6 million; in 2019 its value was set at $10.3 million. In 1997 the Hoyt’s Cinema property was valued at $3.2 million; its 2019 pre-COVID assessment was $700,000 less and the theaters have been dark for most of 2020.
Meanwhile, the value of residential real estate, thanks to a housing shortage, low mortgage rates, and other factors, has been rising. That increase in wealth on paper becomes a growing burden, though, if the household income used to pay property taxes is flat or falling.
Local property taxes also jump when the state finds a new way to downshift costs to cities and towns, as it did when it stopped kicking in a portion of municipal worker pension costs. Similar downshifts could conceivably occur again as the state struggles to balance its pandemic budget.
These threats to homeowners’ ability to pay property taxes, or even hang onto their homes, coincide with the socially distanced meetings of yet another school funding commission – this one funded with a half-million dollars of taxpayer money. Its task is to determine the cost of an adequate education – it’s not the $4,502 the state claims – and find a constitutional way for the state to pay for it. The commission isn’t forbidden from recommending the levy of a broad-based tax, but, come on, this is New Hampshire.
My guess is there will be yet another attempt to amend the state constitution to shed the state’s responsibility to pay for an adequate education for every student and permit the targeting of limited state aid to the neediest districts. The low-balled state estimate for the cost of an adequate education, with current per-pupil spending topping $16,000, won’t stand. More money will be required.
The politically easiest way to raise the extra money would be to raise the statewide property tax. That means, guess what, homeowners and renters would have to pay even more. This column is a look through the glass darkly but it would be foolhardy, especially these days, to avert one’s eyes and hope all will be well.
(Ralph Jimenez lives in Concord and is a member of the Monitor’s editorial board.)
