Ten years ago today, following the retirement of New Hampshire’s David Souter from the U.S. Supreme Court, the Senate began deliberating the historic nomination of Justice Sonia Sotomayor to take his place.
Sotomayor was not your typical Supreme Court nominee. Nor was the president who appointed her typical.
Indeed, while President Barack Obama began his selection process by laying out a familiar set of qualifications – “a sharp and independent mind and a record of excellence and integrity” as well as dedication “to the rule of law (and) the appropriate limits of the judicial role” – he did not leave it there.
Enter the contentious “e” word, empathy, that would cause more than a passing spell of heartburn to the 30 white male Republican senators who ultimately voted against Sotomayor’s nomination.
By elevating “that quality of empathy, of understanding and identifying with people’s hopes and struggles,” President Obama introduced a judicial qualification at once foreign and, we argue, self-evident to the making of a good judge. It is a concept we believe Gov. Chris Sununu would do well to consider as he seeks to reset the nomination process for chief justice of the New Hampshire Supreme Court, after the Executive Council’s 3-2 rejection of Attorney General Gordon MacDonald this month.
What do we mean by “empathy” and where might such a consideration lead in the case of New Hampshire’s next Supreme Court chief?
We begin with what empathy is not. It is not, as Senate opponents of Justice Sotomayor’s nomination contended, the same thing as prejudice (a preconceived opinion not based on fact or experience) or even sympathy (support in the form of shared feelings or opinions). It does not result in the “corruption” of our judicial system or “a brave new world where words have no true meaning and judges are free to decide what facts they choose to see,” as then-senator (and later attorney general) Jeff Sessions maintained during the nomination process. In a word, it is not something to be feared.
Rather, empathy – the ability to understand and share the feelings of others – is at the heart of a successful life and community. It is essential to who we are and who we strive to be as humans. Far from being at odds with justice or impartiality, empathy and justice are mutually reinforcing. When we stand before a judge to defend our most basic rights of life, liberty and property, isn’t it natural to expect the judge will also stand, at least for a moment, in our shoes?
If empathy is a quality we seek, descriptive representation is its indispensable accompaniment: People in power must reflect the people themselves. Although every human being is endowed with empathic abilities, we naturally find it easier to experience fellow feeling toward people like us. We are riddled with implicit biases, forged subconsciously over our lifetimes, which may or may not align with our declared beliefs and which very often favor our own social group at the expense of others. Even one of us, a white man married to a American African with a Ph.D., exhibits pro-white bias on the Implicit Association Test, the product of an all-white childhood in small-town New Hampshire?
Judges are not exempt from such bias, especially when it comes to stereotyping women and people of color. Indeed, a large and growing body of empirical research has found that biographical (descriptive) and ideological characteristics of judges really do matter when it comes to meting out justice with impartiality – that, for instance, people with darker skin receive longer prison terms from predominantly white male judges when convicted of the same crime as lighter-skinned people. It is a topic of ongoing concern to the American Bar Association.
Thus, for empathy and impartiality to be achieved in courts of law, judges – like the juries they impanel in a trial – must be more reflective of the population at large. What’s more, diversity has long been found to be a good in itself, whether in stock portfolios or biological systems or the halls of power.
At a time when just two out of the 109 justices to serve on our nation’s highest court were female, and two more had been people of color, President Obama sought to elevate a justice with more than just impeccable legal credentials and experience – someone whose life experience put her in closer contact with the large majority of Americans who are not white and male. His choice of the first Latina associate justice on the Supreme Court was lauded by countless Americans who had long felt unrepresented and under-served in American courts of law.
The time has come for a similar recognition of the importance of empathy and representation on New Hampshire’s highest court and across the judiciary. In our state’s long history, only three women have served on the N.H. Supreme Court and just one is seated alongside four men today. Not a single person of color has been appointed to the Supreme Court and few, if any, have taken their place on the lower courts.
Considering women make up more than half of New Hampshire’s population and also outnumber men in law schools, we urge Gov. Sununu to seek and consider a highly qualified female judge or attorney for chief justice. Indeed, nearly one in three superior court judges in New Hampshire is female – far from gender parity but still an ample supply of eligible candidates. One such highly qualified candidate is the pioneering chief justice of the N.H. Superior Court, Tina Nadeau, who has earned national regard for launching the state drug courts as a highly impactful and empathic response to the ongoing opioid epidemic.
Granite Staters deserve more than a respected lawyer for our next state Supreme Court chief. We deserve a person, or rather an entire judiciary, that understands and comes to reflect the breadth and depth of who we are as a people. Then and only then will we truly advance the cause of “liberty and justice for all.”
(Dan Weeks is a former Executive Council candidate who works in renewable energy. Sindiso Mnisi Weeks, a lawyer, is assistant professor of public policy at UMass Boston and clerked for the former deputy chief justice of the South African Constitutional Court. They live in Nashua with their kids.)
