Democratic gubernatorial candidate Colin Van Ostern listens during a televised debate at New England College in Henniker on Wednesday, Oct. 5, 2016. (ELIZABETH FRANTZ / Monitor staff)
Democratic gubernatorial candidate Colin Van Ostern listens during a televised debate at New England College in Henniker on Wednesday, Oct. 5, 2016. (ELIZABETH FRANTZ / Monitor staff) Credit: ELIZABETH FRANTZ

Tom Sherman is one of the 424 state lawmakers who will vote Wednesday in the much-anticipated election for New Hampshire secretary of state.

And with the clock ticking toward the showdown, the Democratic state senator-elect says he remains undecided on whether he’ll support Bill Gardner, who’s running for a 22nd two-year term as New Hampshire’s top election official, or challenger Colin Van Ostern.

“What will make the biggest difference is what’s best for the people of New Hampshire,” Sherman told the Monitor on Monday.

The gastroenterologist from Rye and former state representative said he’ll sit down Tuesday separately with Gardner and Van Ostern before he makes his decision on whom to support.

Democratic senator-elect Jon Morgan from Brentwood doesn’t need until Tuesday to make up his mind.

While he lamented “the politicization of the office,” and cited the amount of fundraising that’s gone on in the race as a factor in his decision, explaining that “it plays a role in how I look at this,” Morgan said he would back Van Ostern in Wednesday’s vote.

Morgan said he met with Gardner on Saturday and said the secretary of state told him if re-elected, it would likely be his last term.

“I will tell you it factored into my decision and helped me get a clearer and better understanding of why he’s doing this after having served for so long. Why another term,” Morgan told the Monitor.

Gardner, known nationally as one of the chief guardians of New Hampshire’s treasured primary status, is also the longest-serving secretary of state in the nation.

The former Democratic state representative is now facing his most challenging re-election bid in decades from Van Ostern. The former executive councilor and 2016 Democratic gubernatorial nominee, who’s 39, wasn’t born when the now-70-year-old Gardner was first elected as secretary of state.

In an interview Thursday with the Monitor, Gardner hinted that if he’s re-elected, the upcoming term may be his swan song.

“It could be,” Gardner said. “I have a special reason why I want to do this one,” Gardner explained, referring to his bid for another two-year term. “I wouldn’t have the same reason for the next one.”

That “special reason” is the upcoming 100th-anniversary celebration of New Hampshire’s status as the first-in-the-nation presidential primary. The Granite State held its first primary in 1916, but it wasn’t until four years later that the state’s contest led off the presidential nominating calendar.

“I think if we do this one right and we have the appropriate celebration about it, it just makes it stronger for whoever comes after this,” Gardner said, looking ahead to his eventual successor.

On Monday, two former governors – Republican Steve Merrill and Democrat John Lynch – expressed their support for Gardner and cautioned about the importance of the office.

“This cannot become a partisan office,” said Lynch, who left office in 2013 after four terms.

Merrill, who served two terms in the 1990s, said the secretary of state shouldn’t be beholden to political interests, both in overseeing elections at the state level and protecting New Hampshire’s first-in-the-nation primary.

“To keep the New Hampshire primary, we need the office of the secretary of state to be above reproach, above question,” he said. “The secretary of state must be bipartisan, in fact, nonpartisan.”

State Sen. Lou D’Allesandro, who taught the future secretary of state civics in high school in Manchester decades ago, is a longtime Gardner supporter.

“I think it’s good for him (Gardner) to let people know what’s going on,” D’Allesandro told the Monitor.

“Certainly people want to know about the future obviously. In their consideration, they may take that in mind,” added D’Allesdandro, known as ‘the dean’ of the state Senate.

Gardner’s impeccable reputation among state lawmakers has taken a hit with Democrats the past two years, thanks to his participation on President Donald Trump’s controversial and now disbanded voter integrity commission. Many Democrats are also very angry over Gardner’s support for two GOP sponsored bills signed into law by Republican Gov. Chris Sununu that tighten the state’s voter eligibility requirements, which they characterize as voter suppression measures.

Last month Gardner suffered a setback, as state House Democrats, meeting behind closed doors in their first caucus since they convincingly recaptured the chamber’s majority Nov. 6, handed Gardner a major vote of no confidence. In a non-binding ballot, the representatives overwhelmingly supported Van Ostern over Gardner.

Most Republicans, who lost their state House and Senate majorities in last month’s elections, appear to support Gardner. Many view Van Ostern as overly political Democratic operative. And some claim that Van Ostern would use the position as a stepping stone to higher office. They also point to the large amount of money Van Ostern raised to support his bid.

Since announcing his candidacy in March, Van Ostern’s been actively campaigning for the job. His “Free and Fair New Hampshire” political action committee raised over $200,000 in donations and spent the money to promote his proposals to reform and modernize the office, including holding over 200 forums around the state with legislative candidates.

The fundraising didn’t bother Sherman.

“It costs money to get your message out. The only thing we want to be clear about is where does the money come from,” he said.

“I’m particularly sensitive to the need to raise enough money to get your message out,” Sherman continued. “That’s what Colin has done. That’s what I did. That’s what everyone who’s run for office has done. It doesn’t make it political. It’s what you have to do to be able to reach the people you need to reach.”

(Material from the Associated Press was used in this report.)