Linda Stephenson, who lives close to the Hoit Road Marsh in East Concord, snowshoes on the frozen pond on Wednesday, January 12. 2022.
Linda Stephenson, who lives close to the Hoit Road Marsh in East Concord, snowshoes on the frozen pond on Wednesday, January 12. 2022. Credit: GEOFF FORESTER

A late addition to the state budget three years ago that banned motorcycles from riding on the frozen surface of Hoit Road Marsh – to the relief of neighbors – is on the verge of being repealed, allowing riders back on the ice after several winters of silence.

The state Senate passed House Bill 571 by voice vote earlier this month to reverse the Democrat-led initiative from 2019 that created a first-of-its-kind ban on a large body of water in the state. The bill had already passed the House of Representatives and will now head to Gov. Chris Sununu, who can sign it, veto it or let it become law without his signature.

Ever since the ban was tucked into a state budget rider bill by former State Sen. Dan Feltes at the request of Concord Mayor Jim Bouley, several Republicans and longtime riders complained about the process that bypassed the normal legislative procedures and never allowed for any debate or discussion. The ban came at the behest of nearby property owners – including a former city employee – who complained about the noisy and unruly riders.

Winter riders pushed back against claims their sport was harming wildlife and rattling the dishes in nearby homes. They said statements made against them were misleading or just plain false.

The bill to repeal the ban gave the two sides a forum to air their grievances. Neighbors maintained the riders and their parked vehicles clog the road and hinder emergency vehicles. The sounds of the motorcycles going around and around a frozen oval makes it nearly impossible to share the ice for events, like snowshoeing or cross country skiing on a sunny day.

Some speculated that riders had deliberately fiddled with their engines to make them even louder than normal.

It’s impossible for the public to use the marsh for any activity when riders are present, James Stever of Concord testified to the Senate Transportation Committee in February, adding that since the ban went into effect, the marsh has been peaceful.

Riders and other supporters of the repeal insist that motorcycles have been riding on that particular body of water for at least 40 years, and the recreation is ingrained in the Granite State’s identity.

It remains to be seen if the bill becomes law and riders return if the two sides can reach a compromise. Neighbors insist that saying riders don’t listen and don’t care about their concerns or the wildlife. Riders say they feel unfairly targeted.

“I’ve gone there, and these guys are not doing anything illegal,” Captain Mike Eastman of N.H. Fish and Game said by phone in February. “People are speculating. The impact I see is the two-legged wildlife that lives around the pond.”

Bodies of water larger than 10 acres come under state Fish and Game jurisdiction, not city governance, which is why the state, not the city, has authority. Fish and Game has always prided itself on opening frozen bodies of water for motorized winter use, including landing planes on the ice of Lake Winnipesaukee, with few restrictions.

Amid all the other legislative activity, this bill has stirred interest partly because of the way the ban was implemented in the first place.

“It passed in a real controversial way,” House Clerk Paul Smith said by phone. “It’s definitely been an issue the past couple of years.”

Senate testimony referenced Suzi Pegg, Concord’s former new economic development director, who purchased a house near the marsh when she was hired by the city, unaware of the noise created by 20 or so motorcycles moving 55 mph on winter weekends. While she’s no longer working for the city, she had testified in favor of keeping the ban on several occasions, including when she was being paid by taxpayers.

“If that kind of noise goes on, I won’t be able to work from home,” she said in 2021. “It will be mission impossible.”

Bouley said by phone last week that Pegg never approached him. He said a homeowner in the marsh area had emailed him in 2019 with his concerns, prompting Bouley to visit the marsh to hear for himself how much noise the bikes were making. He concluded a ban was justified.

“I took what he said and went to listen for myself,” Bouley said by phone last week. “I confirmed that what he said was indeed correct.”

Bouley conferred with Feltes, a State Senator and fellow Democrat from Concord, who added a one-line provision into the budget banning bikes on the pond. Feltes has since moved away and lives in Iowa now.

The ban immediately went into effect with the passage of the state budget. The battle lines were drawn with GOP lawmakers biding their time, waiting to overturn the original statute that they believed moved through the Legislature in an underhanded manner.

Sununu’s spokesman did not indicate whether the governor supports or opposes the repeal.