×

Jury awards more than $274M in billboard defamation case

  • Michael Gill


Associated Press
Friday, September 29, 2017

The owner of a New Hampshire mortgage company who used electronic billboards to accuse three businessmen of crimes is liable for $274.5 million in damages in a defamation lawsuit against him, a jury found Friday.

The plaintiffs’ lawyer said he believes the jury award is the largest in the state’s history. In 2013, a jury found Exxon Mobil must pay $236 million to help clean groundwater contaminated with a gasoline additive known as MTBE.

Michael Gill, head of The Mortgage Specialists, has targeted other businessmen, politicians, lawyers, and judges in his electronic signs through the years.

He put up images of an auto dealer CEO, a banker and a developer, accompanied by the words “drug dealer” and “extortion,” on a large billboard outside his Manchester office near the Mall of New Hampshire and off a busy highway. He also made similar references to them online and on radio and television.

The businessmen had donated money to the development of a nonprofit drug and alcohol recovery treatment center. They sued Gill, saying he falsely accused them of crimes and demonstrated “ill will, evil motive, intent to injure and wanton disregard” for their rights.

A judge found Gill had defamed AutoFair owner Andy Crews, Manchester developer Dick Anagnost and Primary Bank founder William Greiner and was liable for damages. A trial was held this week to determine the amount.

“The size of the verdict will forever be the answer to Gill’s false statements,” said Steven Gordon, a lawyer who represented the businessmen.

“These men are community leaders who have given greatly to their community” Gordon said in a statement. “Gill’s statements were evil. In our system of justice, facts are determined in court rooms and not on the internet. We are grateful and humbled by the jury’s verdict. The size of the verdict will forever be the answer to Gill’s false statements. The enormity of the verdict will begin the process of restoration and healing for the Anagnost, Crews and Greiner families.”

Gill represented himself, but left before a jury was picked, calling the proceeding a criminal enterprise.

Crews, the auto dealership CEO, testified he didn’t understand why he was targeted. He said the attacks hurt his family and his business.

“Somebody had to turn around and stop the bully,” WMUR reported him saying in court.