A protracted legal dispute between the developer hoping to tear down the Steeplegate Mall and JCPenney, the lone remaining anchor store, has come to a close, with the retailer formally dropping its suit.
The news opens the door for the mall redevelopment project to move through the city permitting process, but one obstacle ramins: an ongoing legal dispute with another tenant, the Zoo Health Club.
Onyx Partners, which has plans to tear down the mall and build around 600 apartments along with a Costco and Whole Foods, began pursuing demolition of the mall in 2024. While its plans moved through the approval process, the developer said the largely empty mall had become a magnet for trespassing and crime.
JCPenney sued to block the teardown, citing language in its lease, which runs through 2030, that the mall would remain a mall.
After more than a year a dragging legal dispute, the mall space was put on the lease market, in search of new tenants. City leaders got the impression that the redevelopment plan had been shelved.
In April of this year, city hall announced that the dispute with JCPenney had been resolved and that the project would regain its momentum. However, the legal dispute remained open in court until now.
Over the summer, the Steeplegate project has been before the planning board multiple times, as Onyx and the city work through details about traffic and the timing of the project with major sewer upgrades coming to the Heights. JCPenney has long been absent from its submitted plans.
Across the country, JCPenney has been closing hundreds of stores and its unclear if the Concord location will remain open and for how long.
Onyx and JCPenney, contacted via their respective legal representatives, did not respond to requests for comment.
The redevelopment plans have meant multiple court entanglements for Onyx. It remains in a landlord-tenant dispute with the Zoo Health Club. That case is pencilled for a March trial. Another dispute with the owner of a smaller piece of property that holds a TDBank has been resolved
The Concord Planning Board extended its sign-off on a demolition plan from Onyx earlier this year. An inquiry to the City of Concord about the status of demolition permits did not receive a response.
