New Hampshire, which relies on property taxes for nearly two-thirds of its revenue, has the most regressive tax system in the nation.
The state’s wealthiest residents pay, on average, about 2 percent of their income in property taxes, the middle class 4 to 6 percent and the poor 8.3 percent or more. The pain caused by this system was evident in the Monitor’s recent three-part series on the impact of the tax burden.
It’s always been bad for low-income property owners, but it’s gotten much worse.
Property taxes in Merrimack County have risen by 25 percent since 2008 while the incomes of the near poor have stagnated or fallen. Savings, including money put away by elderly homeowners, continues to be eroded by interest rates that can be 1 percent or less. People on fixed incomes must sacrifice mightily to stay in their homes. Some fail.
Making matters much worse, New Hampshire is one of the states that charge a credit-card-level 18 percent interest rate on delinquent property taxes. That rate is confiscatory. It may force Larry Davis, a retired stone mason in Franklin whose plight was described in Tuesday’s paper, out of his modest lifelong home.
Davis lives on income from Social Security that, after a $500 per month child support payment, leaves him barely enough to survive on let alone pay property taxes in a community with one of the highest tax rates in the state. Nor does New Hampshire have a homestead exemption that forgives the taxes on some portion of a home’s value, a tool that can make the system more progressive. Davis is hardly alone in his plight.
The problem has been evident for decades, but nothing has been done about it because of the state’s vaunted “Pledge” to oppose a broad-based sales or income tax. No gubernatorial candidate can expect to succeed as an income tax supporter, and no New Hampshire governor has run for national office as an income tax supporter. No 2016 gubernatorial candidate backs an income tax, nor does Gov. Maggie Hassan, a candidate for U.S. Senate.
In 1999, a Republican-controlled House and Democratic Senate passed very similar bills establishing an income tax. New Hampshire was, and remains, one of only two states without one and the action made national news, only to die when Democratic governor and senatorial hopeful Jeanne Shaheen threatened to veto a combined bill.
The bill, named for its bipartisan sponsors, Rep. Liz Hager and Sen. Clif Below, called for a 3.3 percent income tax on incomes over $22,000 and a $250,000 property tax exemption on primary homes. The result would have been lower business taxes and an increase in the bill for owners of second homes, and more money to truly adequately fund public education.
This year, a similar bill sponsored by Concord Rep. Paul Henle will come before the new Legislature and governor.
Called the N.H. Tax Shift Plan, it would establish a 3.75 percent income tax but lower property taxes by an estimated $400 million, repeal the statewide education property tax and the Business Enterprise Tax, and lower the Business Profits Tax from 8.5 percent to 4 percent and reinstate state revenue sharing with cities and towns.
Henle’s proposal is not our dream bill, which would include a homestead exemption to better aid people like Davis and a lowering of the interest rate on back taxes to 12 percent. But it is a starting point for a serious state discussion about how to help keep the elderly and near-poor in their homes while rebuilding New Hampshire’s infrastructure and lowering public college costs to stem the flow of young people out of state.
That discussion is overdue. Kindly neighbors came to Davis’s aid and paid his back taxes for him, but few in his position have been or will be as fortunate.
