Even amid heightened concerns around the country of government officials using new technology to conduct business in secret and evade transparency laws, New Hampshire lawmakers had been free to use good, old email to communicate outside the public eye for years.
Then House Chief of Staff Terry Pfaff pulled the plug on the private legislative distribution list. Pfaff said he’d grown concerned it was being used in violation of the state’s right-to-know law.
“There were sequential emails taking place that were discussing pending legislation that was bordering on the edge of the right-to-know rules and even our rules within the House,” Pfaff said.
The shutdown comes at a time of heightened concern about government transparency as new technology makes it easier for public officials to send electronic messages in secret.
An investigation by the Associated Press shed light on other states where lawmakers are attempting to pass legislation to make clear that governmental communications are subject to public records laws even in an era of rapid technological advances, and government officials using private smartphones and social media accounts.
New Hampshire’s distribution list of all state lawmakers was originally created so legislative staff members “had the opportunity to, with one fell swoop, contact all members,” Pfaff said.
Over the years, others outside state government gained access to the list. Pfaff suspects someone accidentally hit “reply all” and opened the list to outside sources.
Once the list was accessed from outside, Pfaff said, “voluminous” amounts of information was sent to addresses on the list.
Some lawmakers started to use it inappropriately.
“People were using it for fundraising on a government site,” Pfaff said.
Others asked to be taken off the list altogether.
After much review, Pfaff eventually made the decision to shut the list down and “err on the side of transparency.”
While no challenges against the legality of the list were ever filed, Pfaff said it would be better to close it down to avoid any problems in the future. He said the decision was well-received by all but four or five of New Hampshire’s representatives.
Despite his concerns about transparency, Pfaff maintained the list was “never meant to be in the general public.”
Citing legislative privilege, Pfaff said some conversations between lawmakers should not be disclosed. Additionally, legislative work products are not considered public either.
Pfaff said that, while the vast majority of lawmakers praised his decision, some weren’t thrilled.
One of them is Harrison deBree, who unsuccessfully ran for a representative seat in Dover and is now running as a Republican in Newmarket. He works in information technology.
DeBree has started his own list for lawmakers’ emails without the official go-ahead from the House. Pfaff said anyone could do it because the emails of all representatives are available on the State House website.
Pfaff said he has warned members of the House to be wary of using unofficial lists like DeBree’s and to be careful not to violate the open-records laws.
“You want to have public discussions in the public, properly noticed,” Pfaff said. “That’s how this system works, and it makes sure that there’s pure transparency for the general public to see what’s going on with their elected officials. That’s our goal.”
The Monitor requested the emails Pfaff sent regarding the decision to shut down the list, and any responses he received. Pfaff said he doesn’t share emails and his “first blush would be to deny” a right-to-know request. That request is now pending.
(Jacob Dawson can be reached at 272-6414 ext. 8325, jdawson@cmonitor.com or on Twitter @jaked156.)
