The State House in Concord, N.H., is seen on May 18, 2017.
The State House in Concord, N.H., is seen on May 18, 2017. Credit: Sarah Kinney

This month’s shutdown of an email distribution list including all state representatives was meant to prevent lawmakers from communicating off the books and stem potential violation of the right-to-know law, according to House Chief of Staff Terry Pfaff.

But Pfaff’s decision hasn’t silenced lawmakers on the shutdown itself – some lamented the loss of easy legislative contacts, and others saw a devious partisan motive.

Rep. Amanda Bouldin, D-Manchester, was adamant in her criticism.

“I believe that with this change, Republicans sought only to muzzle their most embarrassing members, not to observe the (right-to-know) law,” Bouldin wrote in an email along with the original message sent by Pfaff. Pfaff later released the email himself after a right-to-know request from the Monitor.

Rep. Christy Bartlett, D-Concord, also disagreed with the decision, though she didn’t point to partisan misdeeds as the reason.

“Communication can be very cumbersome,” she said. “It’s very hard to be in touch with 393 reps in one fell swoop.”

Pfaff said the conversations to take the list down had been going on for months. The issue was largely brought to his attention by other staffers, he said, and prompted by reps using the list to conduct fundraising, write inappropriate messages, and exchange sequential emails with others relating to pending legislation, which he said could violate open-meetings laws.

There were also concerns the list was infiltrated by outside sources, as well as complaints about spam.

“I’m glad it’s gone,” said Rep. Bill Kuch, R-Bow. “I was getting a bunch of junk mail and it was too much.”

Since the shutdown, Kuch said he’s had a much easier time speaking with constituents, cutting the need to wade through fraudulent clutter in his inbox.

“The constituents write me and it pops up and I’m happy,” Kuch said.

Bouldin wasn’t convinced.

“I tell people not to just email your legislator, but all of them,” she said. “Now, it’s harder to talk to everyone.”

And Bartlett reasserted the need for access.

“I think that we should be able to contact all our colleagues anyway,” she said.

Bartlett and Bouldin said the conversations that led to the shutdown have been happening since they joined the list, with email chains often devolving into gripe sessions, members talking about their clothes or descriptions of what lawmakers had for breakfast that day.

Bouldin cited many instances of people using the list incorrectly – some reps would reply-all by accident, leading to chains of dozens of emails relating to a single topic, often not legislative in nature.

But without the email list, Bouldin said she’s afraid those conversations will only take place on a different medium from now on.

“A lot of legislators are on Facebook, and a lot of them talk politics on Facebook,” Bouldin said. “Sometimes it’s just a fact of humanity – when you try to stop something, it just moves into darkness and you can’t control it.”

For Bouldin, a major issue with the shutdown for her is the ability for constituents to talk with their representative. She said lobbyists openly roam the halls of the State House, speaking with legislators.

“It hits the average citizen more because they don’t have the time to email 400 people, but a lobbyist does. They do have the time, they do have the money,” she said.

Questioning the rationale of open-meetings and right-to-know laws, Bouldin said she always treated the list as if it was open to the public, though Pfaff said that was never the intent. By discontinuing the list, Bouldin said, it will only be “enabling secret conversations.”

Rep. Renny Cushing, D-Hampton, said he understood the concern people had about the list violating the law but was surprised when the shutdown happened.

“There were probably exchanges that took place on the list that got pretty close to being deliberative rather than informative,” he said.

Cushing voiced mixed feelings about the list. He said he would receive hundreds of emails a day from totally random people, some outside the state, making it hard to filter them and find authentic communications from his constituents or colleagues.

While the shutdown ends the official distribution list, Pfaff has admitted he can’t stop people from creating their own using publicly available email addresses.

Bouldin, Bartlett and Cushing all echoed one similar theme: They aren’t convinced the decision was solely based on observance of the right-to-know law.

While Bouldin pointed to quieting embarrassing Republicans, Bartlett said she didn’t believe Pfaff had the authority to make such a move without Republican leadership approaching him about it. Cushing said he felt some people’s personalities may have influenced the shutdown.

But Cushing said he did find the list itself helpful when other members, particularly those of the other party, would post about events they were hosting. He said seeing hundreds of opinions helps him form his.

“I oftentimes wrestle with what my position should be, and I try to get as much information as I can,” Cushing said.

(Jacob Dawson can be reached at 272-6414 ext. 8325, jdawson@cmonitor.com or on Twitter @jaked156.)