Bill Gardner
Bill Gardner Credit: Jim Cole

Bill Gardner says a lot more than his job is at stake in the upcoming election for New Hampshire secretary of state.

Gardner, known nationally as one of the chief guardians of the state’s treasured century-long status as the first-in-the-nation presidential primary state, is facing a professionally-orchestrated and well-financed challenge from veteran Democrat Colin Van Ostern.

“The independence of the office is at stake,” Gardner told reporters Tuesday.

Since announcing his candidacy in March, Van Ostern has been actively campaigning for the job. His “Free and Fair New Hampshire” political action committee raised more than $200,000 in donations and spent the money to hire three staff members and promote his proposals to reform and modernize the office, including holding more than 200 forums around the state with legislative candidates.

Gardner, who’s running for a 22nd two-year term as the state’s top election official, criticized Van Ostern’s fundraising.

“You don’t have to have a political action committee,” Gardner said. “It’s contrary to the tradition of this office.”

Van Ostern, a former executive councilor and 2016 Democratic gubernatorial nominee, said the money hasn’t been used to take out ads or endorse any candidates that ran for office.

“I get that it’s novel and it’s new, because no one’s run seriously in a couple of decades,” Van Ostern said.

All 424 state senators and representatives who were elected or re-elected two weeks ago will meet at the State House on Dec. 5 to elect a secretary of state for the next two years.

Last week Gardner suffered a setback, as state House Democrats, meeting behind closed doors in their first caucus since they convincingly recaptured the chamber’s majority Nov. 6, handed Gardner a major vote of no confidence. In a non-binding ballot, the representatives overwhelmingly supported Van Ostern over Gardner.

Gardner’s impeccable reputation among state lawmakers has taken a hit with Democrats the past two years, thanks to his participation on President Donald Trump’s controversial and now disbanded voter integrity commission. Many Democrats are also angry over Gardner’s support for two GOP-sponsored bills passed into law the past two years that tighten the state’s voter eligibility requirements, which many characterize as voter suppression measures.

During his address to the House Democrats last week, Gardner promised to hold a forum before the Dec. 5 secretary of state election, where he said he and lawmakers could “go through these allegations and lay everything out on the table.”

On Tuesday, Van Ostern appeared to try and raise the stakes, as he called for an “open forum” which would also include himself.

“We agree that all incoming legislators should have a chance to hear from and ask questions of both individuals actively seeking the position of New Hampshire Secretary of State and who plan to ask the Legislature to consider them as candidates on December 5th,” Van Ostern wrote in a letter addressed to Gardner that was distributed to reporters via email.

He then listed a series of dates and times that he would be available to take part in such a forum.

While Van Ostern’s been campaigning for the office the past eight months, Gardner said he was busy preparing for the state primaries and midterm elections and in the past two weeks, overseeing nearly 20 election recounts.

“This is my, and only my, opportunity to be able to communicate what he has been doing for eight months with all this money that he’s raised,” Gardner explained.

He emphasized that when he addressed the House Democratic caucus, he didn’t ask for their votes but rather appealed to their fairness, urging them to “give me an opportunity to deal with dozens and dozens of these allegations.”

Gardner added that he sent an email to the re-elected and newly-elected state lawmakers – not including those going through recounts – and mentioned that he hasn’t been raising money and he doesn’t have a political action committee.”

Most Republicans, who lost their state Senate and House majorities in this month’s elections, appear to be supporting Gardner. Many in the GOP view Van Ostern as overly political and pro-Democrat. And some claim that Van Ostern would use the position as a stepping stone to higher office positions.

Van Ostern pledged he wouldn’t use the secretary of state’s office to position himself for another gubernatorial run in two years, and said he would be committed to the job.

“If I’m elected to this job, that’s going to be my only focus. I’m not running for anything else in 2020,” Van Ostern said.

While not pointing fingers at Van Ostern, Gardner said that when he first ran for secretary of state more than 40 years ago, he pledged that he wouldn’t use the office as a political stepping stone, and he’s lived up to that.

“There’s never been any speculation of me running for some office over the years,” Gardner said. “Never.”