Former governor John Lynch stumps for Joe Biden at a house party in Wilton in 2020.
Former governor John Lynch stumps for Joe Biden at a house party in Wilton in 2020. Credit: Monadnock Ledger-Transcript file

It’s been 17 years since a challenger defeated a sitting governor of New Hampshire as they ran for reelection.

Could the politician who last accomplished the feat – former Gov. John Lynch – be considering another stab at toppling an incumbent governor?

Two well plugged-in New Hampshire-based Democratic strategists tell the Monitor that they heard Lynch had been mulling a 2022 run about a month ago, but that the former four-term governor had since closed the door to launching a campaign.

But two prominent Granite State Democrats – former state House of Representatives Speaker Steve Shurtleff and longtime state Sen. Lou D’Allesandro – said in separate interviews Thursday on the “New Hampshire Today” radio program that they had heard that Lynch was still considering the possibility of a 2022 gubernatorial run against current three-term GOP Gov. Chris Sununu.

“I personally would love to see Gov. Lynch run again,” said Shurtleff, who served 11 years on the Concord city council.

Earlier this week Sununu made national headlines by announcing he would run for reelection rather than launch a Republican challenge against first-term Democratic Sen. Maggie Hassan, his predecessor in the corner office.

The Monitor reached out to Lynch on Thursday, but had not received a response by time of publication.

In May of 2004, Lynch – a multimillionaire businessman, attorney and University System of New Hampshire trustee – launched a gubernatorial campaign. He easily captured the Democratic Party’s nomination four months later and in November he edged first-term GOP Gov. Craig Benson by two points.

Lynch won reelection in 2006 and 2008 by massive 48 and 42 point margins, before capturing an unprecedented fourth term in 2010 by 7 points during a Republican tidal wave election cycle that saw Democratic incumbents in New Hampshire and across the country ousted from office.

Shurtleff, praising Lynch, said that the former governor was “just as thoughtful and caring” in public as he is in private. He added, “I think that genuineness comes out in him and people appreciate it.”

Longtime New Hampshire Democratic Party chair Ray Buckley emphasized that “Gov. Lynch’s four terms were history making.”

Citing recent polls, Buckley told the Monitor that “if people have a sense that New Hampshire’s going in the wrong track, it would be logical for them to look at the person who had a steady hand through the great economic collapse of 2008-09. He proved himself as a worthy steward of the state, whether it was weather disasters or economic disasters. … He has respect by people across the board and you saw that in his campaigns.”

Pointing to Lynch’s 2009 signing of a bill legalizing same sex marriage, and the progress the governor made on health care and environmental issues, Buckley said Lynch “certainly would provide a very strong platform within the party’s various ideologies” and predicted that “he would be able to unify the party and attract significant voters” if he decided to seek office again.

But the state party chair – spotlighting Sununu’s flagging, but still positive poll numbers – stressed that “there are other candidates who can make the very strong argument to be the party’s nominee and defeat Chris Sununu next November.”

Biden returns to New Hampshire on Tuesday

The White House announced on Thursday that President Joe Biden will travel to Woodstock on Nov. 16 to spotlight how the recently passed Bipartisan Infrastructure Deal will benefit Granite Staters.

The White House noted that the president will “visit a bridge and discuss how the Bipartisan Infrastructure Deal delivers for the American people by repairing and rebuilding the nation’s roads and bridges while strengthening resilience to climate change, improving equity and safety for all users, and creating good-paying, union jobs that grow the economy.”

Since the measure’s final passage through Congress last Friday, Biden’s been touting that the $1 trillion infrastructure bill will ease the nation’s current supply chain problems and the ongoing spike in inflation. On Wednesday, the president visited the port of Baltimore in Maryland to showcase the infrastructure measure.

The day before he’s scheduled to arrive in New Hampshire, the president’s expected to sign the bill into law during a White House ceremony. The measure passed the Senate over the summer, with bipartisan support. Thirteen Republican representatives last week joined nearly all House Democrats in the chamber in voting for the bill.

Biden’s trip to New Hampshire is his first as president. He was last in the state on the day of the presidential primary in February 2020.

While Biden came in a disappointing fifth in the primary, he rebounded with a second place finish in the Nevada caucuses and a landslide victory in the South Carolina primary, ahead of a slew of Super Tuesday triumphs that propelled him to the Democratic nomination. Biden topped then-President Donald Trump by seven points to carry New Hampshire in the 2020 presidential election.