FILE - In this Aug. 28, 1963 file photo, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., head of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, addresses marchers during his "I Have a Dream" speech at the Lincoln Memorial in Washington. (AP Photo/File)
FILE - In this Aug. 28, 1963 file photo, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., head of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, addresses marchers during his "I Have a Dream" speech at the Lincoln Memorial in Washington. (AP Photo/File) Credit: AP Photo

“Don’t touch him, don’t touch him,” yelled Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. on Sept. 28, 1962, while his supporters restrained Roy James, a member of the American Nazi Party. Just as James had punched Dr. King in the face, the famed civil rights leader “dropped his hands like that of a newborn baby,” recalled an eye witness, refusing to defend himself. “We have to pray for him,” said King, sitting down with the man off-stage, telling him he would not press charges and — to the horror of Coretta Scott King — even inviting the attacker to return to his seat.

This is the best of America: Courage. Forgiveness. Dialogue. Compassion, no matter how bad the wound, offers salvation. Hatred rots.

Give us, then, leaders who can match the decency of our next door neighbors. Find us policymakers who care more about the Republic than the title of their office. Stand up courageously, any and all who represent the American nation, if you are willing to shake the hand of a political foe. Debate vigorously in the process. Speak the truth, as you see it, based on mutually verifiable facts. Listen, really listen, to the life experiences that shape your opponent’s thinking. But most of all, wish them well, and make sure they know that, no matter how strong your disagreements, you would rise to defend them should someone wish to hurt them or their family. 

To do these things does not mean denying your convictions. It does not mean betraying your values for false brotherhood and complicity in lies. Rather, it means prioritizing basic decency, the lifeblood of a healthy society, over partisan fervor. It requires caring about the humanity of those we oppose. The strong see a world bigger than themselves. The weak spew bile. 

Yet I — like so many of my countrymen — often fail to live up to these aspirations. Our Republic seemingly teeters at the abyss. Partisanship poisons us. And, looking at my own children, I feel bitter at those I perceive as undermining the stability and prosperity of the country they will inherit. I have too frequently responded with anger at demonstrably false claims from friends and family. But history will soon humble me — my reading of reality is not absolute truth. As I lay awake at night, my chest tightening at a new political outrage, I remember the words of Shakespeare: “The fault, dear Brutus, lies not in the stars, but in ourselves.” Beware arrogance.

So I called a MAGA Republican attorney, who I know cares deeply about the U.S. Constitution and honest reflection. The goal of engaging was to listen as much as to debate — and to find common ground with someone whose views confound me.

I asked him, “How can you support a president whose loyalty to the constitution is in question?” He quietly made clear that he felt uncomfortable with some of the president’s recent remarks — like when Kristen Welker form NBC’s Meet The Press asked him if he needs to uphold the Constitution and he responded “I don’t know” — but noted that the character of the person in the Oval Office does not always determine the effectiveness of their policies, and he thought our current president was effective on policies about which he cared.

I asked why we had to choose between an ethical president or an effective president? We shouldn’t have to, we both ultimately agreed. The American people deserve a president, regardless of party, who is both competent and decent.  

When it was his turn to question me, he asked what had happened to the Democratic Party … when, as he put it, the “far left crazies” took over at the expense of centrist Democrats focused on pocket book issues? I acknowledged that the party had moved further to the left, but that large portions remained in the center. He lamented that the far-left often seemed the most vocal segment of the party.

As we went back-and-forth, we agreed on the need for term limits, which would allow U.S. Representatives and Senators greater leeway to challenge a president without worrying about losing their seat in primaries. Before we hung up, I urged him to speak publicly on the points of principle we had discussed, and to speak frankly when any policymaker’s actions undermine the constitutional foundations of freedom on which this Republic stands.  

No matter how difficult the current political environment, reach out to any and all willing to engage in fact-based dialogue. Have the strength — like Dr. King — to absorb unfair blows, but also the courage to engage anew thereafter. Reject the inevitability of conflict. Feel empowered by the reality that what you do (and don’t do) matters more than ever before. Strength of character must prevail. Our children’s future is at stake.

Brandon K. Gauthier, Ph.D. is a historian and educator from Concord. He is the author of “Before Evil: Young Lenin, Hitler, Stalin, Mussolini, Mao, and Kim” and specializes in the history of totalitarian states.