With the financial issues facing Concord, city council must find a way to resolve the acrimonious relationships that hinder its ability to address serious problems. The first step toward resolution is understanding the problem. As reported, much of the conflict arises from questions posed that concern how the city manages its capital reserves funds. These questions have not been answered.
Currently, the city has a number of capital reserve accounts, similar to savings accounts, established to pay for future capital outlays related to specific city facilities or functions. They benefit the city and taxpayers by smoothing expenditures for capital expenses.
By law, cities are also allowed to set up expendable trust funds to pay operation and maintenance expenses related to public facilities. RSA 34:1-a designates these funds as “Non-Capital Reserve Funds.” Expendable trust funds are used to pay for maintenance, operations or specific public purposes, and are funded by appropriations from the general fund.
By state statute, capital and non-capital reserve funds are considered trust funds and subject to similar requirements. Both funds must be retained in segregated accounts and not co-mingled. To set up a capital reserve fund, city council must hold a public hearing on the budget and adopt a capital improvement budget and program. After the fund is established, the city’s trustees of trust funds have custody over all trust funds and authority to invest and financially manage them. As trustees, they have a fiduciary duty to ensure that the trusts are administered in accordance with the directives of the city in creating the trusts.
The city manager appoints the trustees for Concord. According to the city’s website, the Concord Trustees of Trust Funds failed to meet between Oct. 14, 2021 to Nov. 24, 2025, during which the city spent money from its capital reserve funds. Only recently have the Trustees of Trust Funds starting meeting on a regular basis after questions were raised about their statutory custodial role over the city’s capital reserve funds.
A related issue concerning the city’s capital reserve funds concerns how the funds were spent. By law, the expenditure of funds from capital reserve accounts must be spent for the purposes described in the fund and be used to pay for capital expenses. The city has used funds in its capital reserve account for non-capital expenses and for expenses not described in the capital reserve fund.
At a recent meeting, the City Manager proposed adding language to the described purposes of a dozen or so capital reserve funds that would allow funds from those trusts to be used for non-capital expenditures, including operation and maintenance. For example, the City Wide Community Center capital reserve fund that originally was designated for use in connection with the Community Center, under the new language, can be used for “other recreation-related purposes as approved by the City Council.”
Questions have been raised regarding whether broadening the use of these funds is legally sufficient to allow the city to spend capital reserve funds for general operation and maintenance, as well as whether it can be applied retroactively to spending from that account that has already occurred. In 2016, the city put $3.5 million into a Recreation Capital Reserve account for future projects related to the city-wide Community Center. Only $838,000 remains and there is no evidence any funds were directed to the CIP.
The addition of the proposed language to the city’s capital reserve funds essentially converts these funds into non-capital reserve funds. By state statute, changing the purpose of a capital reserve fund or converting the fund into an expendable trust fund requires a 2/3 vote of the governing body. Under the conversion statute, once the change of purpose is approved, the capital reserve account is closed and the funds in it are transferred to a newly created expendable trust fund created for the expanded purposes. The Trustees of Trust Funds take custody of the funds.
In response to questions raised concerning the changed purposes of the capital reserve funds, the city says that it actions are transparent. Transparency is no answer to the question of whether the city is properly managing its capital reserve funds. The questions posed need to be answered and until they are answered, the questions will keep being asked.
In addition to the capital reserve funds, questions have been raised about the Beaver Meadow donation. According to New Hampshire Municipal Association guidance, money raised by fundraising cannot be deposited either in a capital reserve fund or the city’s general funds. It must be deposited in a separate fund under the custody of the Trustees of Trust Funds that has a designated purpose and must be invested and accounted for separately from, and not co-mingled with, other amounts appropriated.
According to the Monitor article, the donated money was simply deposited in city accounts. The city cannot identify how the fundraised money was spent. This again is not a “transparency” issue. Was a separate account set up under the custody of the Trustees of Trust Funds? Based on the testimony given at the Council hearing, it remains unclear.
To resolve the tension at city council, the City Manager must answer the questions raised about capital reserve funds and donations forthrightly. Without answers, the questions will continue to be asked and tensions will remain.
Leslie Ludtke lives in Concord.
