Working across the aisle?

We often hear calls to “work across the aisle,” as if bipartisanship means going along with the other party just to get along. Recently, social media posts pointed to the New Hampshire House Democratic leadership race — where Rep. Alexis Simpson was nominated for Speaker over Rep. Jim Maggiore — to argue Democrats refuse to work with Republicans. They note that on partisan votes, Simpson voted with her party 99% of the time, while Maggiore voted with Democrats 91% of the time.

That framing misses a vital truth: working together does not mean compromising your core values or abandoning the people you represent.

Voters elect representatives to stand up for working families, not to rubber-stamp harmful policies to earn a “bipartisan” label. Looking at the 9% of the time Rep. Maggiore broke with Democrats shows why the caucus chose Simpson’s leadership instead. According to the New Hampshire Bulletin and NH Journal, Maggiore broke ranks to vote:

  • To table a minimum wage increase.
  • To cut funding for Office of the Child Advocate.
  • For Medicaid work requirements.
  • To remove student IDs from accepted voter ID.
  • To bring back hard labor as criminal punishment.

True bipartisanship happens when Republicans and Democrats find common ground on shared goals like lowering property taxes and fixing housing. Democrats didn’t reject cooperation by choosing Simpson; they simply affirmed that working across the aisle requires knowing where you stand and refusing to sacrifice core principles.

Erica Russell, Northfield