Of the many reasons being espoused for the results of the recent election, a vote for change comes up often. However, there is less agreement about what needs to be changed.
Some point out the need to control the rising cost of fuel, food and healthcare. Others see the need to end support to nations at war and end U.S. involvement in war. Then there is the need to control the overreach of Homeland Security and immigration officials. Also, there are those who feel the need to close the widening gap between the wealthy and the average citizen.
However, all of these situations are the result of a pervasive attitude that warrants change. It is the attitude of self-interest. For example, self-interest is the primary motivation of the Trump administration. The government seeks to secure its self-interest bias with the power of executive orders and financial pressure. It secures its interest in maintaining wealth and power with tariffs, with the deportation of millions of immigrants, with the infringement on the policies of colleges and education institutions, with the reductions in foreign and domestic aid and with tax reform that favors the wealthy.
Other examples of this self-interest attitude are legion. For example, the executive order to end USAID is based upon the understanding that the United States is reaping no benefit from the aid it has been giving. In her book “Call It Evil,” Susan Neiman writes, “(The Trump) administration cut more than $5 billion of already allocated foreign aid … an ideological assault on the very idea of generosity.” Generosity is considered a weakness that erodes self-interest and the ability to gain wealth and power.
Free market capitalism is a prime motivator for self-interest. Neiman references Ha-Joon Chang who writes in his book, “23 Things They Don’t Tell You About Capitalism,” “Free market ideology is built on the belief that people won’t do anything unless they are paid for it…” As Neiman observes, the ideology of self-interest refuses to recognize any moral obligations. Without a moral motivation, self-interest leads to “a host of evil consequences: cruelty and corruption, cynicism and opportunism, complacency and resignation … a denial of the possibility of goodness.”
It would seem that the change our country needs is a social political change from the assumption that humanity is best served with actions of blatant self-interest. Free market competition benefits the wealthy who seek to accumulate more wealth. Power and influence are the assets of fascism.
However, contrary to what the prevailing administration would have us believe, human beings are at their best when they spurn self-interest by expressing a concern for the wellbeing of others: a moral and ethical motivation. It is not a weakness. For example, in times of disaster or war, people who act out of concern for others are celebrated for their actions. In spite of what the administration would have us believe, the same concern for others in the realm of social and economic life is a strength to be celebrated. The stronger the community, of which each of us is a part, the better off each of the community members.
The defeat at the polls of those candidates who thrive on the advocacy of self-interest opens the possibility for change. Neiman writes, “no one in a free society should die for want of food, shelter, or medical care.” She also wrote, “people can work together to make significant improvements in the real conditions in their own and others’ lives.”
Neiman offers three moral principles which override the concept of self-interest. The first is universalism. It is “the conviction that behind all the differences of time and space that separate us, human beings are connected in a wealth of ways.” The second principle is that “justice and power are fundamentally different. … Sheer power often determines unjust outcomes.” It would seem that justice is not guided by the accumulation of power but instead by a commitment to universalism and the third principle that “the idea of progress is possible.”
The results of the recent election have provided an inflection point for change from rampant self-interest to the possibility of universal justice and progress for all of humanity.
John Buttrick writes from his Vermont Folk Rocker in his Concord home, Minds Crossing.
