If you had walked into a New Hampshire town hall 40 years ago and asked to see a public record, the town clerk would have pulled a binder from a shelf, made a photocopy, maybe charged you a dime. You asked, and your government answered, because the record belonged to you in the first place.
Our Right-to-Know Law, RSA 91-A, put that arrangement into statute. Its preamble reads like something the founders might have written: “Openness in the conduct of public business is essential to a democratic society.” I believe that sentence after a career in New Hampshire local government. Openness is not a burden. It’s the job.
What has changed is who is asking?
The requests arriving at town halls, county offices and state agencies are less and less often from people. Many are generated by software and sent in volume by data firms with no connection to New Hampshire. They ask for years of records, then package and sell what we send. As the Union Leader reported in May, the state Commission on Government Efficiency found that the volume of requests has “placed a growing strain on agency resources, consuming months of staff time and delaying responses to the very citizens that the law was designed to serve.” The Department of Safety alone logged 3,472 requests in 2025. The commission recommended prioritizing New Hampshire residents and routing out-of-state and bulk requests through fee-based systems.
A manager in an Upper Valley town sorts the strain into two piles. One is data mining: sweeping requests for decades of paper files, with no effort to narrow them. The other is more subtle, and I confess it annoys me more. Professionals who once visited the town office and reviewed permit files themselves now expect staff to find, sort, scan and deliver everything, so they can work from a screen and monetize the data.
Towns have improvised. That Upper Valley town does not email records, hands over electronic copies on a sealed thumb drive for pickup and asks requesters to review files in person and flag what they want copied. A Seacoast municipality asks anyone filing a large request to confirm they will collect it in person, which usually ends the inquiry. These workarounds are sensible. They are also fragile. One court case or statutory amendment could erase them, and they do nothing for state agencies.
So, ideas for the Legislature. If I could have only one, it would be the second. But here is the menu.
Let agencies recover real costs. Today towns can generally charge for copying, but not for the staff hours spent searching and reviewing. The federal Freedom of Information Act sorts requesters by use. Commercial requesters pay for search, review and copying. Everyone else gets two free hours of search time and 100 pages free. A New Hampshire fee schedule that recovers staff time from commercial and bulk requesters, and spares residents and the press, would put the cost on those who profit.
Then my choice: Limit the law to New Hampshire residents and taxpayers, with a legal-interest exception. The Massachusetts driver contesting a ticket on the Everett Turnpike, the out-of-state party to a lawsuit, and the summer family paying property taxes on a camp here keep full access. The Supreme Court unanimously upheld Virginia’s citizens-only records law in 2013, so this approach would rest on solid ground.
Two smaller items. Illinois treats anyone filing 50 requests in a year, 15 in a month or seven in a week as a recurrent requester with a longer response time, excludes news media and academic requesters and lets agencies decline a request whose burden outweighs the public interest, after offering the requester a chance to narrow it. That is a fair answer to the rare requester who uses the law to intentionally tie up public servants. And the in-person inspection practices some towns rely on should be explicitly written into statute, so making records available at the office clearly satisfies the law.
The Right-to-Know Law was written for the people who own the government, which is all of us in New Hampshire. It still works as intended when a neighbor asks what happened at Tuesday night’s meeting. It was never meant to be a vending machine, and the property taxpayers of this state should not be asked to stock it for free.
Todd Selig is the long-time Administrator for the Town of Durham, which operates under a Council-Manager form of government.
