The downtown shopping plaza Capital Shopping Center in June 2026. Credit: CATHERINE McLAUGHLIN / Monitor

The former JoAnn store in the Capitol Shopping Center will be turned into three small restaurants and two stores, the latest move by owners of a 65-year-old plaza that in some ways has found itself in the wrong place as times have changed.

“It’s weird to see a shopping center like this so close to a downtown area. What we’re trying to do is make the center fit in better with the downtown environment,” said Mark Newman, vice president for development of Brixmore Property Group, which owns the plaza, during a hearing before the city Planning Board on Wednesday. He noted that competition for customers wasn’t other downtown retailers so much as plazas “across the river” along Loudon Road.

Capitol Shopping Center was built starting in 1961, replacing the elegant but decaying Boston & Maine Railroad train station that had been sitting empty after passenger service ended two years earlier. That was before shopping malls and stand-alone plazas became common on arterial roads.

In recent years, the plaza has made a number of changes, including building stand-alone restaurants and stores separate from the main strip.

The 18,920-square-foot JoAnn Fabrics has been empty since the company went out of business in early 2025. Leasing it is unlikely, Newman told the board, especially since the plaza has two other similar-sized vacancies in the recently vacated Marshall’s and a space left empty behind the Burlington store after it downsized.

“This category space size is problematic” with what are known as “junior box” spaces getting harder to lease as retailers change their focus, Newman said. “The best plan is to break the space up into five smaller spaces, which is a category that’s actually missing from this center.”

This also gives the plaza a chance to add more restaurants, which it lacks compared to other plazas of the same size, Newman said.

Of the five proposed spaces, a lease has been signed for a restaurant chain known as Wonder, which mostly serves takeout and pickup rather than sit-down dining, and a discount shoe store called Famous Footwear. The other three new spaces, two for restaurants and one for retail, are yet to be leased.

Hanging over all plans for the plaza is the knowledge that the inelegant state parking garage nearby is closed and will eventually be torn down, causing a ripple effect.

“There’s going to be significant change to the entire Storrs Street area in coming years as the state parking garage comes down. All of that land is going to become infinitely more valuable,” said Tim Thompson, the city’s assistant director of community development. “You’re going to see some significant redevelopment in that entire section over the next five to 10 years.”

As is often the case with shopping plazas, much of the planning board discussion concerned parking. Change from one retailer to three restaurants would require many more parking spaces, per city standards, but the plaza has so many parking spaces that the requirement was waived.

The complication is that the parking lot is often used by people going downtown, another reflection of the plaza’s atypical location.

“A lot of the people who park there are not going to the plaza itself. They are avoiding the city’s parking system and parking on a private lot where they don’t have to pay anything. That’s s why you have the perception of this being an overloaded parking lot,” Thompson noted. “It’s not because of he tenant demand on the site.”

The board discussed changes in enforcement to keep people from using it as free parking as well as efforts to free up more public space in the covered Storrs Street parking garage opposite the plaza. Many of the garage’s spaces are currently leased to downtown businesses.

Newman said retailers are trying to get away from big parking lots where many spaces were often open.

“We’re going to make for a tighter parking,” he said. “Now people are going to have to walk more.”

David Brooks can be reached at dbrooks@cmonitor.com. Sign up for his Granite Geek weekly email newsletter at granitegeek.org.