parks and rec concord
parks and rec concord

In my small city of Concord, my family has enjoyed many Parks and Recreation Department offerings over the years from basketball to golf to archery. But not anymore.

Why? The city now requires parents to sign a release that says “We hereby discharge the city of Concord … from all liabilities … I understand this release and waiver includes any claim or action based on the negligence, action, or inaction of any Releasee or otherwise.”

What does this mean in plain English? It means parents must agree not only to accept negligence but also to excuse it, and parents must give up their fundamental right to seek damages in court if a child is injured or killed by the city’s negligence. Such a requirement is unconscionable. Giving up a civil right should not be a condition to play a sport. Yet, because I said no to this unreasonable demand, my son was excluded from a sport he loved.

My follow-up conversation with Parks and Recreation revealed that most parents sign the waiver without questioning it. How could this be? I suspect that many parents are too busy to read it or they read and sign without considering the implications. Nobody thinks about getting hurt until it happens to them.

One thing I love about my city is the way we have welcomed refugee families and funded recreation scholarships so that parents and children from Nepal, Rwanda and Sudan can meet New Hampshire kids and play together on our soccer fields and basketball courts. These non-English-speaking families may not fully understand the legalese in the contract they are signing or the rights they are giving away. The city should not be taking advantage of them or of anybody.

Such a waiver may be legal, but it should not be. I hope the city’s standard is not “can we get away with this legally?” but rather, “what is the right thing to do?” I understand that cities wish to protect themselves from liability, but they have no right to protect themselves from liability for problems they cause. The best way for cities to protect themselves is to not be negligent.

I have seen this kind of contract more and more in other places. For example, amusement parks and ski areas. Agree to the demand, excuse the park from liability, or else you can’t play. People should not have to give up a fundamental right in order to play or ski, especially if the ski area is subject to public accommodation laws. Excluding people who do not agree to an unreasonable demand is a form of discrimination. It is discrimination not against a protected class, but discrimination against all people who exercise good judgment.

The city sent me a refund check and I put my outrage on pause. Then a friend from another state was injured at an amusement park. She says it was due to the park’s negligence. She was unable to walk for months and is still recovering. The amusement park refused to take responsibility because, that’s right, my friend had signed a waiver permitting negligence.

I understand that skiing and archery and roller coaster riding have some inherent dangers and that ski areas should not be held responsible for injuries caused by gravity or by skiers who take foolish risks. But I do not believe that businesses should be excused from responsibility for their own negligence.

Perhaps a good lawyer can pierce these waivers. But that has not happened for my injured friend. Her lawyer dropped her. Why? Personal injury lawyers tend to work for a contingency, so they choose cases they are likely to win. What makes a win unlikely? A client who has signed a waiver excusing negligence.

My friend will have to find a new lawyer and pay him or her an hourly rate, but that may not be an option for everyone who signs a waiver. Lawyers are available only to those who can afford them.

In my conversations, I have found that some friends and neighbors dismiss these concerns for reasons that range from “these never hold up in court” to “these hold in court so well that they protect the city.”

I suspect that neither extreme is true, especially the belief that this waiver protects the city. People who are inclined to file frivolous lawsuits will do so no matter what. Those who are injured by the city and can afford a lawyer will pierce the waiver. Who does that leave? People who don’t understand their rights or who cannot afford to exercise them. This waiver has a disparate impact on non-English speakers and new Americans.

I have presented my concerns to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee. I appreciate that they were polite listeners, but they have not yet made a recommendation. Even if they do address the problem in Concord, it remains in many other places.

There ought to be a law preventing cities and businesses from even asking for this concession, much less demanding it as a condition to use a publicly accessible service or facility. In fact, there is a law in the United Kingdom. The Unfair Contracts Term Act of 1977 declares that “a person cannot by reference to any contract term … exclude or restrict his liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence.”

That is all the more reason we need a federal statute to provide clarity, consistency and protection. If you share these concerns, I encourage you to think globally and act locally. Reach out to the Concord Parks and Recreation Department and to our federal representatives.

(Jon Kelly lives in Penacook.)