A “My Turn” column on April 3 about the recently approved Hall Street solar project in Concord raises some appropriate concerns from both an economic and environmental standpoint.
However, some of the statements made are incorrect or unfounded and require clarification so the benefits and drawbacks of the project can be viewed objectively.
This project will install solar panels owned by a third party on city land currently leased for agricultural use. Concord would then purchase the power at a locked-in rate over a 20-year period.
The article claims the price the city would pay is higher than current electricity rates; while this may be true in the present, it does not stand to reason that this will be the case over the course of two decades.
Electricity rates have been increasing at an average of 2 percent each year, meaning that the city could soon be paying less than the current rate and would continue to do so for a number of years.
Another concern raised by the article is the subsidization of the project by state funds. In reality, the project’s large size makes it ineligible for a rebate or grant from New Hampshire’s Renewable Energy Fund.
In addition, the fear of ratepayers being forced to pay more for the excess energy produced by the system under net metering is exaggerated given that the exported energy produced will only receive the energy supply rate, while the city and the project owner will continue to pay for all transmission charges, distribution charges, taxes and upgrades to the electric system.
When speaking in support of the project, one city councilor said: The capital city should be “a leader in moving us to renewable energy sources.” Why should Concord shy away from this opportunity to showcase the city’s, and state’s, dedication to clean energy? Furthermore, the city is not proposing to clear new land for the site, but to use existing land that is already open.
Although currently under an agricultural lease set to end, the solar panels would take up only about a quarter of the site, leaving plenty of room for local agriculture to continue.
In addition, there seems to be a general consensus that this decision will not serve as a precedent for removing future parcels of land from agriculture. The council has shown awareness of economic and environmental issues by choosing the Hall Street project over several others that were proposed, citing it as the only viable option from both perspectives.
Concord’s energy master plan supports many goals that will be realized by projects such as this one, including increased use of renewable energy systems, and sustainable land use.
The approval of the Hall Street solar project is a step in the right direction toward meeting these goals for the city, while also providing statewide leadership toward implementing clean energy.
(Kevin Porter lives in Concord.)
