In response to Robert Fried’s recent column (“How we get to earn an income tax,”Sunday Monitor Forum, Jan. 20): If Fried truly were interested in listening to the many, as he calls them, “hard-working, freedom-loving” New Hampshire citizens who oppose an income tax, he would discover that they are neither Koch Kool-Aid drinkers nor conservative talk-radio junkies. Instead, he would find rather educated and thoughtful people who believe that New Hampshire’s tax system is economically advantageous and supports good educational opportunities throughout the state.
Despite almost 30 years of beating the income tax drum with numerous educational funding lawsuits, and despite three Democratic governors, Fried and his allies have failed repeatedly to convince New Hampshire residents that passing an income tax is in their economic self-interest.
Instead of considering the possibility that he might be wrong, Fried forges ahead and says 30 years of failure can be reversed by viewing the world through the eyes of those who have only “blighted future prospects” and distrust government. Show compassion to the ignorant and dispossessed, and they will support an income tax.
For Fried, this new strategy will reverse their 30 years of failure and an income tax will be ours at last.
This sounds nonsensical, and it is.
One thing that New Hampshire residents know is that adding a new tax will not lower their tax burden. If the problem that Fried wants to solve with an income tax is the familiar canard that poor people in New Hampshire pay too much in taxes and receive too little in education for their children, an income tax is not the answer. One doesn’t have to distrust government to know that adding a new tax increases taxes rather than lowers them.
With an income tax, the residents of New Hampshire will pay more in taxes and will have less say and less local control in how their tax money is spent.
Maine and Vermont both have income taxes. Maine’s lowest rate is 5.8 percent and Vermont’s maximum rate is 8.75 percent, the eighth-highest in the country. With hefty income taxes, and sales taxes as well, Maine and Vermont should have much better schools than New Hampshire. But they don’t.
A recent U.S. News and World Report ranks New Hampshire schools as fourth best nationally, followed by Vermont at eighth and Maine at 19th. How can that be? Even more surprising is that both Vermont and Maine, both of which have sales and income taxes, are losing population. Vermont is so desperate to attract new residents that it has now resorted to paying people $10,000 dollars to move there.
New Hampshire is the only one of the three states with a population gain. Apparently, people prefer New Hampshire, a state with, according to Fried, “blighted future prospects” to either Maine or Vermont. Perhaps it is the lower tax environment and the highly ranked schools that attract these new residents to New Hampshire.
Fried offers no details about just how an income tax would improve education opportunities or advance the economic interest of those who are dispossessed in the present system. Does Fried seriously think that when income tax dollars flow into the state that the New Hampshire Legislature is better equipped than are local school districts to determine how education tax dollars will be spent?
With competing state interests and expenses, such as unfunded state and municipal pension liabilities, does Fried believe that the state will turn over the revenues raised from an income tax to local school districts and allow local school districts to decide how to spend state tax dollars?
Although Fried condemns the property tax for its alleged regressiveness, he fails entirely to explain how an income tax would not be equally as “regressive.” Under the New Hampshire Constitution, a New Hampshire income tax may only be imposed at a uniform rate. It could not be made progressive with higher rates for the wealthy.
When Fried is out earning support for an income tax is he going to explain that a constitutional amendment is required to make an income tax progressive?
This is not to say that more cannot be done to address pressing social needs in New Hampshire resulting from poverty, drug use and social inequality. These are real issues that will persist regardless of whether New Hampshire has an income tax. Changing the school finance system is not going to cure these substantial social problems.
Fried tells us in his article that the variation in property tax rates among districts in New Hampshire is “cruelly regressive” and grossly unequal. This is not true. Property tax rates differ among districts in New Hampshire because districts have different total values of property and spend different amounts of money for their schools. The differences in spending and in property valuation among districts are neither evidence of social inequality nor produced by the influence of, as he terms it, “wealthy, big corporations and cynical politicians.” Rather, a large part of the difference in value and rates stem from the type of property in a district and the specific demands posed by the schools in the district. Some of the highest property value districts are populated by some of the lowest income people.
To say that a district is rich or poor does not mean that the people who live in the district are rich or poor. Rich people live in property-poor districts and poor people live in property-rich districts. Districts with utilities, vacation homes, and large businesses and manufacturing plants generally have higher property-tax values, while districts that are primarily residential generally have lower property tax values. The mix and type of property in a district is a far greater determinant of a district’s tax base than is the income of the people who live in the district.
In the original Claremont educational funding case, the plaintiffs inadvertently demonstrated this fact when they selected Lincoln as a “rich” comparison district to Lisbon.
(Leslie Ludtke lives in Concord.)
