‘Help Wanted” signs hang in hundreds of windows. Short employees, some businesses have reduced the hours they’re open. Others have closed. At 2.6%, New Hampshire’s unemployment rate is, save for South Dakota at 2.5%, the lowest in the land. Employers are desperate for workers. But with the race to fill vacant positions underway, the state is poised to shoot itself in the foot.
It will do that, and lose what’s become an intense regional competition for workers, if Gov. Chris Sununu vetoes Senate Bill 1, legislation that provides employees up to 12 weeks of paid family leave. The Legislature lacks the Republican support necessary to override Sununu’s veto.
The bill is actuarially sound. Versions of it have been used by other states for years. The benefits it provides, time off at partial pay to care for a newborn, ill spouse or aged parent, will be funded by a 0.5% tax on payroll that can be paid by employers or employees or shared between them. Benefits would be distributed through the state’s Labor Security Department, which already runs the unemployment insurance program.
The governor claims to have a rival plan. It involves voluntary participation with coverage purchased from private insurers.
There is no there there, at least for now, to Sununu and Vermont Republican Gov. Phil Scott’s proposal to use state employees to provide a pool of buyers big enough to attract the interest of private insurers. The union representing Vermont’s state employees rejected the idea. New Hampshire’s state employees union has been noncommittal. Nor is it clear that insurers are interested in selling paid family leave coverage, at least at a price employers and employees would be willing to pay.
The governor says that SB 1 would impose a new income tax. Not exactly. Taxes on earnings, whether from payroll, interest, dividends or capital gains, are income taxes. Though the 0.5% employer/employee contribution is based on a worker’s earnings, like unemployment, health or dental insurance it pays not to support government but to purchase a defined benefit.
Experience in California and a handful of other states suggest that the benefits of paid family leave, payroll contributions aside, may pay for themselves. It costs hundreds and in some cases thousands of dollars to recruit and train an employee hired to replace one that, had paid leave been available, would have returned to the job. Workers who take paid leave to deal with a birth or a family medical emergency are five times more likely to return to their job than workers who leave because they feel they have no choice.
Providing paid family leave is good for employee morale and promotes a better relationship between employers and workers. That contributes to increased productivity. It’s also humane, good for children and the right thing to do.
Rhode Island has required paid family leave since 2014. Massachusetts’ paid family leave law was signed by that state’s Republican governor this year. Vermont’s legislature may have the votes to override its gubernatorial veto. Lawmakers in Maine and Connecticut appear likely to vote in favor of family leave.
New Hampshire is already the only state that doesn’t mandate that employers pay a minimum wage. If it becomes the only New England state whose employers don’t provide paid family leave, the “Help Wanted” signs will remain in windows until they’re sun-bleached and torn, and New Hampshire will lose the race.
