Woody debris in a pile on city-owned conservation land. Courtesy photo from Kevin Porter.
Woody debris in a pile on city-owned conservation land. Courtesy photo from Kevin Porter.

Kevin Porter lives in Concord and owns a NH Certified tree farm.

Councilor Jennifer Kretovic recently quoted the local farming community who expressed their belief that “as stewards of the land – we, the city, are not doing a good job.” I would have to agree, and while this statement was about farmland, this is just as true (perhaps more so) when it comes to timberland.

This is mainly because our forests in central New Hampshire need to be actively managed to be healthy and resilient; just letting them be will not lead to good outcomes and strong, productive growth.This is not to assign blame. It’s simply a matter of budgeting and labor; the work of intensive forestry is slow, tough work.

The public would not expect city employees to be out in the woods eliminating invasives, pruning trees and managing beech.Small, local owners, however, can do this work on their own accord without needing to worry about the hourly cost.It is this dynamic, and the ability to have a long-term outlook, that led Aldo Leopold, a godfather of the modern conservation movement, to write that he believed local family owners (as opposed to corporations or the government) to be the best stewards of timberland.

This holds as true today as when it was written in the 1940s, but the Conservation Commission continues to crowd out local ownership to achieve a top-down approach to land use that prioritizes recreation for a small subset of the community.

I have suggested to the Conservation Commission an approach to transitioning small parcels of timberland to private ownership under permanent conservation easements, but this was quickly dismissed by certain members before it could even be fully explored. It is disappointing that producing better forest outcomes and saving taxpayer money does not seem to be priorities for the Conservation Commission.

Equally disappointing is the opacity of this institution. It was just reported in the Concord Monitor that the Conservation Commission held an illegal meeting on April 7 to discuss the future of Gully Hill where the public was not noticed. Further, I have requested several times information on the governance and composition of the Conservation Commission. It appears that of the current Conservation Commission members, there are no agricultural producers, no forest products professionals/timberland owners, and no individuals from historically underrepresented groups represented. I would welcome an open response from the Conservation Commission on these matters, as I’m sure other members of the public would. Regardless, it is time for new perspectives and new approaches.

To be clear, no one is suggesting that the Conservation Commission should sell any of the wonderful, heavily used recreation areas in town. However, the Commission has acquired numerous landlocked, off-the-beaten-path parcels that probably 99% of people that live in Concord will never see or recreate on. Is this the best use of public money when there is an alternative that will continue to preserve the land in conservation, produce better forest outcomes and leverage private resources?

A proposed framework will soon be submitted to the City Council relative to the disposition of small parcels of timberland in Concord in order to facilitate intensive forestry by private owners. These lands would be subject to ongoing conservation easements to ensure that they stay as forests and stay accessible to the public. Included in this framework will be recommendations for equitably redeploying the proceeds from these sales for green space initiatives in communities that have historically been underinvested by the Conservation Commission.

I ask those that have an interest in this matter and think that there are better ways to spend our tax dollars and manage our forests to submit their input and to help provide input from those that have been left out or ignored by the Conservation Commission.