About 10 years ago, baseball historian Ray Carbone first heard of the 19th-century Black ballplayer with ties to Laconia.
Carbone, researching for his book about titans from the Lakes Region, chose to add a segment on baseball and discovered that Bud Fowler was special, both as a professional player and an executive. He was seen as a leader and promoter of the sport, a pioneer for the Negro Leagues of the 20th century.
He was a great player, which is why Fowler was able to join the all-white town team from Laconia. He earned praise from white opponents, during a highly charged period in American history, with racism raging just two decades after the Civil War.
He broke barriers, becoming the first Black player ever to play professional ball on a team with white players only, and, some documentation suggests, the first to manage a team with white players, 60 years before Jackie Robinson broke Major League Baseball’s color line.
Fowler was a player-manager for Laconia.
But the story, to Carbone’s surprise, didn’t end with his discovery and subsequent chapter in his book. Two weeks ago, the player who was buried in an unmarked grave more than 100 years ago, the Black man who caught Carbone’s eye before the 2015 publication of his book, was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame, the most hallowed ground in American sports.
The same Hall that had enshrined Robinson in 1962, 50 years after Fowler’s death. The same Hall that keeps players alive forever. Players like Babe Ruth.
Few saw this coming. Carbone sure didn’t.
“Historians were aware of him, but few others were,” said Carbone, an ex-newspaper man who now runs his own business in Warner that produces content for various media platforms.
“I tracked down some of (their stories) and found photos online. I knew they knew about him, but I did not suspect he would rise to this level.”
Carbone is a writer, a former staffer at the Laconia Citizen and a contributor to such media outlets as TheBoston Globe.
Now 70, he grew up near Yankee Stadium and rooted for Mickey Mantle, a Hall of Famer and Yankee great, in the early 1960s. However, with the counterculture tugging at his heart later in the decade, Carbone abandoned baseball, saying his hippie friends thought it “was so uncool.”
He got older and uncool, his interest in baseball returning. He went to Emerson College in Boston and the unthinkable occurred: He switched allegiance, from the Yankees to the Red Sox.
He loved the way Dwight Evans played right field at Fenway Park, where quirky dimensions can be a nightmare for opposing players.
He attended the historic one-game playoff between the Yankees and Red Sox in 1978 at Fenway. He’s been in the Granite State for 25 years and began his media company in Warner in 2003.
His book, Legendary Locals of the Lakes Region of New Hampshire, was finished in 2015, but not before Carbone had checked the Laconia Library for information on baseball in the Granite State.
He knew the history here, the players who had reached the big leagues, like Red Rolfe and Bob Tewksbury and Carlton Fisk and Mike Flanagan.
But maybe there was something else he could use, a new nugget for his book.
“I was surprised there was as much as there was,” Carbone said. “I thought, ‘Let’s see what else I could find.’ I found out about Fowler. His name came up, and it said he played on the Laconia Town Team before the 20th century.”
That sounded odd. A Black man playing high-level baseball with white players? That long ago?
Yet Carbone found local periodicals from the day, with stories saying Fowler had an executive’s instincts. He organized offseason barnstorming tours so big leaguers could earn extra money.
He played wherever he could, for a few bucks. He never stayed too long, the racism and the unstable structure of the game at the time always pushing against him, always reminding him that work would have to be found somewhere else, soon.
He played in Pueblo, Colo., and Topeka, Kan., and Binghamton, N.Y.. He was named captain of a white team in Vermont.
He felt the sting of racism yet somehow endured, finding his way to the Laconia club in the late 1870s.
Newspapers said he was a great player, a pitcher and a second baseman who helped Laconia beat the Boston Beaneaters, an all-white team playing in the National League, the game’s highest level.
Did he actually manage white players? Carbone found an article from the Society for American Baseball Research that hinted he might have. The gist of the story was that an African American man, before anyone knew about Jackie Robinson, clearly sat outside the box.
“This is maybe the only Black guy on that team at the time,” Carbone said. “All the white players shake his hand. Why? He must have been managing as well.”
Carbone included this unknown Granite State treasure in his book six years ago. Then he moved on.
But last month, Carbone received the list of players being considered for the Hall by the Early Day Committee – an avenue for the induction of players who have been retired for more than 15 years. He saw Fowler’s name.
The player, once a footnote within the state’s rich baseball history, and a tiny footnote at that, was voted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, where only giants of the game reside.
The announcement came on Dec. 5.
“I read the quotes about how he was a pioneer of baseball and that he was really something,” Carbone said. “He drove through the Lakes Region. I don’t know how long he was here, but he was here.”
