A sign on the back of deliveryman Daniel DiDonato's heating oil truck indicates a price of 2.81 a gallon, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in Lewiston, Maine. The amount of aid available to residents of cold weather states for heating costs has increased, but it's unlikely to plug the gap caused by higher energy costs. (AP Photo/Robert F. Bukaty)
A sign on the back of deliveryman Daniel DiDonato's heating oil truck indicates a price of 2.81 a gallon, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in Lewiston, Maine. Credit: AP Photo/Robert F. Bukaty

An Oct. 14 column in these pages argued that New Hampshire had seven months of warning before this heating season. That undercounts it. The state has been through at least five energy crises since 2005, and the impact and actions of those events were documented. The crisis those lessons warned about is now weeks away, and it will land hardest on the households least able to absorb it. The lack of preparation was a choice.

On Nov. 2, the federal government’s weekly survey put New Hampshire heating oil at $6.06 a gallon, the highest price on record and about $2.56 more than a year earlier. Fuel assistance benefits begin Dec. 1, and federal funding for the program is settled only through Dec. 11. The first hard freezes will have come and gone well before Congress decides what comes next.

The record shows what works — and it did not rely on the federal government alone. After Hurricanes Katrina and Rita hit Gulf refineries in 2005, Congress approved an extra $1 billion in heating aid. The bill was signed March 20, 2006, after most of that winter’s bills had been paid.

In the summer of 2008, when heating oil approached $5 a gallon in parts of New Hampshire, Gov. John Lynch joined three other New England governors to demand more federal heating aid. That August, about 100 fuel dealers, advocates and state and local officials met in Portsmouth to plan for what one participant called New England’s “Hurricane Katrina.”

A state law that took effect in late September added $10 million in state money to fuel assistance and $1.2 million for weatherization, and days later Congress approved $5.1 billion for heating assistance, the most the program had ever received. That aid arrived before the cold and before the bills arrived. The Governor and her NHDOE did not make similar pre-emptive moves this year. The costs are up and they are silent.

The record also shows where the damage lands. In December 2008, an ice storm cut power to 432,000 of the state’s 685,000 electric meters, some for 14 days, and nearly 40% of residents rely on private wells with electric pumps, so a rural outage is also a heat and water outage. During the cold snap of late 2017 and early 2018, New England burned more than 2 million barrels of oil to keep the power on, and fuel truck drivers hit federal limits on their hours until emergency orders lifted them. The grid operator warned that same winter that oil delivery trucks may be busy serving heating oil dealers just when power plants need them.

And it shows that the squeeze reaches dealers too. In March 2008, Connecticut’s F&S Oil went bankrupt, leaving more than 2,500 prepaid customers about $3.1 million short. That August, an Exeter dealer warned that price swings and tight credit would drive smaller dealers out of business. In 2014, after a brutal winter, Hudson’s Fred Fuller Oil & Propane filed for bankruptcy owing prepaid customers $5.1 million, and the state had to help steer a sale. When a dealer fails in January, its customers lose heat and money at once.

The NH Department of Energy should know these lessons because it has acted on them. In November 2021, three months before Russia invaded Ukraine, it raised fuel assistance benefits for households by 60%, to as much as $2,520, citing “dramatic projected increases in heating fuels.” In September 2022, the Legislature passed House Bill 2023, which paid a $450 heating benefit and a $200 electric benefit to households earning 60% to 75% of state median income. This year, the department raised the maximum fuel assistance benefit 15%, to $2,500, and the Legislature and the governor tightened the rules for prepaid heating oil, requiring dealers to back those contracts with a bond, futures or inventory. Both help. But the administration’s signature energy initiative this year was a roadmap for next-generation nuclear power, and the state budget moved nearly all of the Renewable Energy Fund into the general fund, with a House committee voting in April to do it again.

The price of oil is only half the story. The other half is who pays it. A July report by the Applied Economics Clinic, commissioned by 350 New Hampshire, found that the 39% of New Hampshire households classified as low-income spent an average of 7% of their income on energy in 2024, compared with 3% for everyone else. Households earning $20,000 or less spent a quarter of their income on energy. That was before the war, when New Hampshire heating oil sold for $3.70 to $4.30 a gallon.

Oil sits at the center of that burden. Heating oil is the most common heating fuel among the state’s low-income households, used by 36% of them. Those households spent an average of 7.9% of their income on energy, and propane households 8.3%. Two-thirds of low-income homeowners heat with oil or propane, and their average energy burden was 9%. Renters are not spared. Most low-income renters have their heating fuel bundled into rent, so the cost reaches them through the landlord.

The strain was showing even then. In 2024, about 21% of New Hampshire households could not pay anything toward an energy bill at least once during the year, and many cut back on food or medicine or kept their homes at unsafe temperatures.

Now add $6 oil. The national association of state energy assistance directors projects that an oil-heated household will spend about $2,300 this winter. For a household earning the low-income average of $43,000, that is more than 5% of income for heat alone, before the electric bill. For a household earning $20,000, it is more than 11%. At today’s price, this year’s top fuel assistance benefit buys about 414 gallons, a third less than last year’s maximum bought a year ago. And federal fuel assistance stops at 60% of state median income, so many families the report counts as low-income get no federal heating help at all. Those are working families who earn too much for federal aid and too little to absorb a $6 winter.

Efficiency is the lasting fix, and the state underinvests there too. In 2024, only 22% of NHSaves spending went to income-eligible programs, though low-income households make up 38% of the population. A weatherized home needs less $6 oil, not only this winter but every winter after.

Not every setback belongs to Concord. Washington canceled the state’s $43.5 million Solar for All grant, and the White House budget again proposes eliminating federal heating assistance. The war with Iran, which squeezed world supplies of diesel and heating oil, was Washington’s decision, not Concord’s. No governor sets the price of heating oil.

But the record of past crises points to decisions that were Concord’s to make. Move money before the cold, not after. Reach the families just above the federal income line. Plan with fuel dealers for a long freeze when oil is scarce. Treat a rural outage as a heat and water emergency. Put efficiency dollars where the burden is highest. None of that required a forecast of events in the Strait of Hormuz. It required agency leaders who know the State’s history and who would put staff to work turning their own files into a plan.

New Hampshire still has time to help people this winter. It no longer has time to do it cheaply. The warnings were never hidden. They were filed. The families who will pay for ignoring them are the ones who can least afford to.

Rebecca Beaulieu is the executive director of 350 New Hampshire.